Breakdown of Onun sessiz kaldığını ben de varsaydım.
Questions & Answers about Onun sessiz kaldığını ben de varsaydım.
Can you break the sentence down word by word?
Yes:
- onun = his / her / its
- sessiz = silent / quiet
- kaldığını = that he/she remained / stayed
- ben de = I too / I also
- varsaydım = I assumed
A very important point is that onun sessiz kaldığını is not just three separate words in meaning. It works as one clause-like noun phrase: that he/she remained silent. That whole chunk is the object of varsaydım.
Does onun mean his or her?
It can mean either, depending on context.
Turkish third-person singular does not mark gender:
- o = he / she / it
- onun = his / her / its
So from onun alone, you cannot know whether the person is male or female. Context tells you.
Why is it onun, not o?
Because in this kind of embedded clause, Turkish usually puts the subject in the genitive case.
Compare:
- O sessiz kaldı. = He/She remained silent.
- Onun sessiz kaldığını... = that he/she remained silent...
This is a very common Turkish pattern:
- subject of the embedded clause → genitive
- verb of the embedded clause → a nominalized form
So onun is not random here; it is required by the structure.
What exactly is kaldığını?
It is a nominalized verb form built from kalmak (to remain / stay).
Roughly:
- kal- = verb root
- -dık / -dik / -duk / -dük = nominalizing suffix
- -ı / -i / -u / -ü = 3rd-person possessive
- -nı / -ni / -nu / -nü = accusative
So:
- kalmak
- → kaldığı = his/her remaining or that he/she remained
- → kaldığını = that same form in the accusative, because it is the object of varsaydım
The k becoming ğ is a normal sound change between vowels.
Where is the word that in Turkish?
There is no separate word here for that.
Instead, Turkish often uses a nominalized clause. So:
- onun sessiz kaldığını
functions like English:
- that he/she remained silent
This is one of the biggest differences between English and Turkish sentence structure. English often uses that; Turkish often uses a verb form like -DIK plus possessive endings.
Why does Turkish say sessiz kalmak here?
Because sessiz kalmak is a very natural expression meaning to remain silent or to stay quiet.
It is slightly different from similar expressions:
- sessiz olmak = to be silent
More stative: describing a condition. - susmak = to become silent / stop talking
Often focuses on the moment of going silent. - sessiz kalmak = to remain/stay silent
Often emphasizes continuing in that state.
So sessiz kaldığını fits well if the idea is that the person stayed silent.
What does ben de mean, and why is de written separately?
Ben de means I too or I also.
The word de here is the additive particle also / too, and it is written separately:
- ben de = I too
- o da = he/she too
This is different from the locative suffix -de / -da meaning in / at / on, which is written attached:
- evde = at home
So:
- ben de = separate particle, also
- evde = attached suffix, in/at
Is ben necessary? Could the sentence just say Onun sessiz kaldığını varsaydım?
Yes, ben could be omitted, because varsaydım already means I assumed.
So:
- Onun sessiz kaldığını varsaydım. = I assumed that he/she remained silent.
However, the original sentence has ben de, which adds a specific meaning: I also assumed it.
That matters, because if you remove ben, you may lose the also meaning or change its scope.
Compare:
- Onun sessiz kaldığını ben de varsaydım.
= I also assumed that he/she remained silent. - Onun sessiz kaldığını varsaydım.
= I assumed that he/she remained silent. - Onun sessiz kaldığını da varsaydım.
= I assumed that too.
That last one is different: there, de applies to the whole object clause, not specifically to I.
Why is the word order like this? Could it be changed?
Yes, it could be changed. Turkish word order is flexible.
The sentence as given:
- Onun sessiz kaldığını ben de varsaydım.
is perfectly natural. It puts the clause onun sessiz kaldığını first, which can help foreground what was assumed.
Another very natural version is:
- Ben de onun sessiz kaldığını varsaydım.
Both are good. The difference is mostly emphasis and information flow.
In general, Turkish often places the main verb at the end, but other parts can move around depending on what the speaker wants to highlight.
What tense is varsaydım?
Here, varsaydım is the simple past, first person singular of varsaymak (to assume / suppose).
Formation:
- varsay- = verb stem
- -dı = past tense
- -m = I
So:
- varsaydım = I assumed
It is a straightforward finite verb form in the main clause.
Is varsaydım the same as sandım or düşündüm?
Not exactly.
They overlap, but the nuance is different:
- varsaymak = to assume / suppose
Often sounds more deliberate, logical, or formal. - sanmak = to think / suppose / believe
Very common in everyday speech; can imply a mistaken belief. - düşünmek = to think
Broader and less specifically assume.
So varsaydım is a good choice if the idea is I made that assumption rather than simply I thought so.
Why is the whole clause onun sessiz kaldığını in the accusative?
Because it is the direct object of varsaydım.
In Turkish, when a whole clause functions as the object of a verb, it can take accusative marking just like a noun phrase.
So in this sentence:
- main verb = varsaydım
- object = onun sessiz kaldığını
That final -nı on kaldığını is the accusative marker attached to the nominalized clause.
This is another sign that Turkish is treating that he/she remained silent as a noun-like object.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning TurkishMaster Turkish — from Onun sessiz kaldığını ben de varsaydım to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions