Breakdown of Hâlbuki siz arayacaktınız; numarayı mı kaybettiniz?
Questions & Answers about Hâlbuki siz arayacaktınız; numarayı mı kaybettiniz?
Hâlbuki means something like but, however, whereas, or even though that was the case. It introduces a contrast with what was expected before.
In this sentence, it signals an idea like:
- But you were going to call...
- However, you were supposed to call...
So it sets up a mild contradiction or surprise.
Yes. The verb ending already tells us the subject is you plural or polite singular, so siz is not strictly necessary.
- arayacaktınız already means you were going to call
- adding siz gives extra emphasis, contrast, or politeness
So siz here can sound like:
- you were the one who were going to call
- but you were supposed to call
It may also simply be there because the speaker wants to be clear or slightly emphatic.