Breakdown of A todo esto, practicábamos la posición abierta.
Questions & Answers about A todo esto, practicábamos la posición abierta.
What does A todo esto mean here? It looks like to all this literally.
Yes, literally it is something like to all this, but in real Spanish it is an idiomatic expression.
In context, A todo esto often means things like:
- meanwhile
- all the while
- by the way
- with all this going on
- in the middle of all this
The exact English equivalent depends on context. It usually connects what follows to a situation already being described.
So a learner should treat A todo esto as a fixed discourse expression, not translate it word by word.
Why is it practicábamos and not practicamos or practicábamos in some other tense?
Practicábamos is the imperfect tense of practicar.
The imperfect is used for things like:
- ongoing actions in the past
- repeated or habitual actions in the past
- background description
So practicábamos suggests we were practising or we used to practise, depending on context.
Compare:
- practicábamos = we were practising / we used to practise
- practicamos = we practised / we practice, depending on context and accent
- practicamos without an accent can also be present tense: we practise
- practicábamos with -ábamos is clearly imperfect
Here, the imperfect fits because it sounds like background information: while everything else was happening, we were practising.
How do I know practicábamos means we?
The ending -ábamos tells you that it is:
So:
- yo practicaba
- tú practicabas
- él/ella practicaba
- nosotros practicábamos
- vosotros practicabais
- ellos practicaban
Spanish often leaves out the subject pronoun because the verb ending already shows who is doing the action. So nosotros is not necessary.
Could I also say estábamos practicando?
Yes, often you could.
- practicábamos = imperfect simple
- estábamos practicando = imperfect progressive
Both can mean we were practising, but there is a slight difference in feel:
- practicábamos can mean either we were practising or we used to practise
- estábamos practicando focuses more strongly on the action being in progress at that moment
So if the idea is background activity, both may work. The simple imperfect is very natural and often preferred unless you really want to stress the ongoing nature of the action.
Why is it la posición abierta and not just posición abierta?
Spanish often uses the definite article more than English does.
So la posición abierta means the open position. In many contexts, Spanish prefers the article when referring to:
- a known position
- a specific technique
- a named posture or configuration
This is especially common in technical, physical, musical, sports, or dance contexts.
Leaving out the article might be possible in some special contexts, but la posición abierta sounds more normal as a complete noun phrase.
Why does abierta come after posición?
In Spanish, adjectives usually come after the noun.
So:
- posición abierta = open position
That is the normal order.
Putting the adjective before the noun is sometimes possible in Spanish, but it usually changes the tone, style, or emphasis. With a technical phrase like this, posición abierta is the standard order.
Why is it abierta and not abierto?
Is posición abierta a fixed expression?
It can be.
It sounds like a term that could belong to a specific field, such as:
- dance
- sport
- music
- body posture or movement
- mechanics or spatial arrangement
In those contexts, posición abierta may function almost like a set term: open position.
Even if it is not a fully fixed expression, it is still a completely normal noun + adjective combination in Spanish.
What is the function of the comma after A todo esto?
The comma shows that A todo esto is a sentence opener or discourse marker, not part of the main clause grammar.
So the structure is basically:
- A todo esto, = introductory expression
- practicábamos la posición abierta. = main clause
This is very natural punctuation in Spanish. It works much like English introductory phrases such as:
- Meanwhile,
- By the way,
- In all this,
Can A todo esto go in other positions in the sentence?
Usually it appears at the beginning, because it introduces or frames what follows.
That is the most natural placement.
In some cases, similar expressions can be moved for stylistic reasons, but with A todo esto, sentence-initial position is by far the most common and idiomatic.
Does practicar always mean to practise in the sense of training?
Very often, yes, but it is broader than that.
Practicar can mean:
- to practise a skill
- to train
- to do regularly
- to carry out
Examples:
- practicar español = to practise Spanish
- practicar deporte = to do sport / practise sport
- practicar una técnica = to practise a technique
So in this sentence, practicábamos la posición abierta is perfectly natural if they were rehearsing or training that position.
Is this sentence more likely to mean we were practising or we used to practise?
On its own, the imperfect allows both readings.
- we were practising if it refers to an action in progress in a past scene
- we used to practise if it refers to a habitual past action
Because of A todo esto, many learners will feel a background in-progress sense more strongly: meanwhile, we were practising...
But the wider context decides the exact interpretation.
Would a Spaniard naturally say this?
Yes, the sentence is natural Spanish.
What makes it sound especially natural is:
- the idiomatic opener A todo esto
- the use of the imperfect practicábamos for background action
- the normal noun phrase la posición abierta
The only thing that depends on context is posición abierta: it sounds most natural if the conversation is about a field where that term makes sense, such as dance, movement, posture, or technique.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from A todo esto, practicábamos la posición abierta to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions