Questions & Answers about Удар был сильным.
- Удар – noun, masculine, singular, nominative. Means “a blow / hit / strike.” It’s the subject of the sentence.
- был – past tense, masculine, singular of быть (“to be”). Here it means “was.”
- сильным – adjective сильный (“strong”), masculine/neuter, singular, instrumental case. It’s a predicate adjective describing удар.
Literal structure: “The blow was strong.”
Russian often uses the instrumental case for a predicate after the verb быть (and some similar verbs) when describing what something was / became / seemed, etc.
- Удар был сильным. – literally: “The blow was (as) strong.” (instrumental)
- This is called the predicate instrumental.
Using the instrumental here is standard and neutral. With adjectives, Russian allows two patterns:
- Nominative predicate:
Удар был сильный. - Instrumental predicate:
Удар был сильным.
Both are grammatically correct. The instrumental often sounds a bit more “complete,” neutral, or literary, while the nominative can sound more conversational or evaluative. In everyday speech, you will hear both; textbooks tend to prefer the instrumental here.