Breakdown of Mamy co prawda latarkę czołową, ale nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej.
Questions & Answers about Mamy co prawda latarkę czołową, ale nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej.
What does co prawda ... ale ... mean?
This is a very common Polish pattern meaning something like:
- it is true that ..., but ...
- admittedly ..., but ...
- we do have ..., but ...
In your sentence:
the speaker is conceding one positive fact and then contrasting it with a more important negative fact.
A very natural English equivalent is:
- We do have a headlamp, but we don’t have a rain jacket.
So co prawda introduces a concession, and ale introduces the contrast.
Why is mamy repeated?
Because Polish often repeats the verb in both parts of a contrast:
- Mamy ... , ale nie mamy ...
Literally: We have ..., but we don’t have ...
This sounds natural and clear in Polish. English sometimes omits the second have, but Polish commonly keeps it.
You might also hear more compressed versions in speech, but the repeated verb is completely standard and often preferred.
Why is there no word for we in the sentence?
Because Polish usually does not need subject pronouns like ja, ty, my, oni unless they are needed for emphasis or contrast.
The verb form already shows the subject:
- mamy = we have
So:
- Mamy already means we have
- Nie mamy already means we do not have
If you said My mamy..., that would sound more emphatic, like we do have...
Why is latarkę written with -ę?
Because latarkę is the accusative singular form of latarka.
The basic form is:
- latarka = flashlight / torch
After an affirmative verb like mamy (we have), a direct object normally goes into the accusative:
- Mamy latarkę. = We have a flashlight.
So:
- latarka → nominative
- latarkę → accusative
This is very common for feminine nouns ending in -a.
Why is it kurtki przeciwdeszczowej and not kurtkę przeciwdeszczową?
Because Polish usually uses the genitive after a negated verb like nie mamy.
Compare:
- Mamy kurtkę przeciwdeszczową. = We have a rain jacket.
- Nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej. = We do not have a rain jacket.
So the negation changes the case of the object:
- affirmative mieć
- negative nie mieć
- genitive
That is why:
- kurtka → kurtkę in the affirmative
- kurtka → kurtki after nie mamy
And the adjective changes with it:
- przeciwdeszczową → przeciwdeszczowej
Why do czołową and przeciwdeszczowej change too?
Because adjectives in Polish must agree with the noun they describe in:
- gender
- number
- case
So:
- latarka czołowa = nominative singular
- latarkę czołową = accusative singular
And:
- kurtka przeciwdeszczowa = nominative singular
- kurtki przeciwdeszczowej = genitive singular
The adjective always follows the noun’s case pattern.
What exactly does latarka czołowa mean?
It means headlamp or head torch.
Literally, it comes from:
- latarka = flashlight / torch
- czołowa = frontal / forehead-related / worn on the front of the head
So latarka czołowa is the kind of light you wear on your head.
In natural English, headlamp is the best translation here.
What does przeciwdeszczowa mean?
Przeciwdeszczowa means rainproof, for rain, or more naturally in this context, rain as in rain jacket.
It is built from:
- przeciw- = against
- deszcz = rain
So kurtka przeciwdeszczowa is literally something like:
- a jacket against rain
In natural English, that is usually:
- rain jacket
- sometimes waterproof jacket, depending on context
Is co prawda a single expression, or can I translate the words separately?
It is best learned as a fixed expression.
Literally:
- co = what
- prawda = truth
But in this phrase, you should not translate word by word. As a set phrase, co prawda means:
- admittedly
- it is true that
- granted
So it is much better to memorize:
- co prawda ... ale ... = admittedly ... but ...
Can co prawda go in a different position in the sentence?
Yes, Polish word order is flexible, and co prawda can appear in slightly different positions, though some sound more natural than others depending on style and emphasis.
For example:
- Mamy co prawda latarkę czołową, ale nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej.
- Co prawda mamy latarkę czołową, ale nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej.
Both are natural.
The version in your sentence puts co prawda just after the verb, which is perfectly normal.
Why is ale used here and not a?
Both a and ale can connect contrasting ideas, but ale is stronger and corresponds more directly to but.
Here the speaker is making a clear contrast:
- we do have one useful thing
- but we do not have another important thing
So ale fits very well.
Very roughly:
- a = and/but, often a milder contrast
- ale = but, stronger and clearer
Is nie mamy written as two words?
Yes. In Polish, nie is written separately from finite verb forms.
So:
- mamy = we have
- nie mamy = we do not have
This is normal for verbs in Polish.
Could the sentence be shortened by leaving out the second noun or verb?
Sometimes, yes, especially in casual speech, but the full version is clearer and more standard for learners:
A native speaker might sometimes shorten things in conversation if the context is obvious, but this complete version is natural, grammatical, and easy to understand.
So for learning purposes, this sentence is a very good model.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from Mamy co prawda latarkę czołową, ale nie mamy kurtki przeciwdeszczowej to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions