Breakdown of Bananen var ikke moden i går, men eplet var godt.
Questions & Answers about Bananen var ikke moden i går, men eplet var godt.
Why are the nouns bananen and eplet in the definite form?
Because Norwegian is referring to the banana and the apple, not just a banana and an apple.
- en banan = a banana
- bananen = the banana
- et eple = an apple
- eplet = the apple
In a sentence like this, Norwegian often uses the definite form when talking about specific things already known from the situation or context.
Why is it moden for the banana, but godt for the apple?
Because adjectives in Norwegian agree with the noun’s gender and sometimes number.
- banan is a common gender noun: en banan
- eple is a neuter noun: et eple
So in the singular:
- common gender: moden
- neuter: godt
That is why you get:
- Bananen var ikke moden
- eplet var godt
This is normal adjective agreement after å være as well.
Why isn’t it modne or gode if the nouns are definite?
Because these adjectives are being used predicatively, not attributively.
In other words, they come after the verb var and describe the subject:
- Bananen var ikke moden
- eplet var godt
When an adjective comes after a verb like er / var / blir, it usually agrees only for gender and number, not for definiteness.
Compare:
- det gode eplet = the good apple
- here the adjective is before the noun, so it takes the definite form gode
- eplet var godt = the apple was good
- here the adjective is after the verb, so it is godt
Why does ikke come after var?
Because in a normal Norwegian main clause, the finite verb usually comes in second position, and ikke usually comes after that verb.
So:
- Bananen = first element
- var = finite verb in second position
- ikke = negation after the verb
That gives:
- Bananen var ikke moden i går
This is a very common pattern in Norwegian main clauses.
What exactly does i går mean, and can it go somewhere else in the sentence?
I går means yesterday.
Yes, it can move, depending on emphasis. For example:
- Bananen var ikke moden i går, men eplet var godt.
- I går var bananen ikke moden, men eplet var godt.
Both are grammatical, but the first version sounds more neutral if you are simply adding the time information. The second puts more focus on yesterday.
Why is the verb var used twice?
Because there are two separate clauses joined by men:
- Bananen var ikke moden i går
- men eplet var godt
In Norwegian, it is completely normal to repeat the verb in the second clause. This is the natural way to say it.
What does men do here?
Men means but.
It connects two ideas that contrast with each other:
- the banana was not ripe
- but the apple was good
So men introduces a contrast, just like but in English.
Why is it var and not er?
Because the sentence is talking about the past.
- er = is
- var = was
Since the sentence includes i går (yesterday), the past tense is needed:
- Bananen var ikke moden i går
Using er would not match i går.
Does godt here mean good, or does it mean something more like tasty?
It can mean both, depending on context. With food, god/godt very often means:
- good
- nice
- tasty
So eplet var godt will usually be understood as the apple tasted good or the apple was nice/tasty.
Why is there no word for the apple was good yesterday in the second half too?
Because Norwegian, like English, often leaves out repeated information when it is already clear.
The sentence says:
- Bananen var ikke moden i går, men eplet var godt.
The time phrase i går naturally carries over in meaning unless the context suggests otherwise. So it is understood as something like:
- The banana wasn’t ripe yesterday, but the apple was good.
If you wanted to be extra explicit, you could repeat i går, but it is usually unnecessary.
What are the dictionary forms of the words in this sentence?
Here are the basic forms:
- bananen → en banan
- var → past tense of å være
- ikke → not
- moden → ripe
- i går → yesterday
- men → but
- eplet → et eple
- godt → adjective from god
So the sentence gives you examples of:
- definite nouns
- the past tense of å være
- negation
- adjective agreement
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning NorwegianMaster Norwegian — from Bananen var ikke moden i går, men eplet var godt to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions