Breakdown of Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
Questions & Answers about Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
Both memerlukan and perlukan come from the base word perlu (need).
memerlukan + noun
- Slightly more formal and complete.
- Common in writing and polite speech.
- Example: Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri.
perlukan + noun
- Also correct, a bit more conversational.
- Formed like (Subject) + perlukan + object.
- Example: Saya perlukan jadual waktu galeri.
In this sentence, both are grammatically fine:
- Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri...
- Saya perlukan jadual waktu galeri...
The meaning is the same. The version with memerlukan just feels a bit more formal/standard.
The phrase is a noun phrase built like this:
- jadual = schedule / timetable
- waktu = time(s)
- galeri = gallery
Malay normally puts the main noun first and then adds more specific information after it:
- jadual waktu = timetable of times (i.e. schedule)
- jadual waktu galeri = the gallery’s timetable / the gallery’s opening hours
So:
- jadual (main noun)
→ jadual waktu (what kind of timetable? A timetable of times)
→ jadual waktu galeri (whose timetable? The gallery’s timetable)
You could also just say jadual galeri (“gallery schedule”), but jadual waktu galeri makes it clear you mean the hours or timetable, not some other kind of schedule.
Yes, in real life you might hear shorter versions:
- jadual galeri – can mean the gallery’s schedule (timetable, events, or hours, depending on context).
- waktu galeri – less common on its own, sounds incomplete (just “gallery times”).
Common alternatives are:
- jadual buka galeri = the gallery’s opening schedule
- waktu buka galeri = the gallery’s opening hours
jadual waktu galeri is clear, correct, and neutral. The shorter versions can work, but may rely more on context.
supaya means so that / in order that. It introduces a purpose or goal.
In your sentence:
- ... jadual waktu galeri supaya saya tahu ...
→ “... the gallery schedule so that I know ...”
It’s not “because” (which is kerana or sebab). Compare:
Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
= I need it so that / in order that I know when I can come again.Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri kerana saya mahu datang lagi.
= I need it because I want to come again.
So supaya clearly expresses purpose, not reason.
Yes, but with small nuance differences:
agar – very similar to supaya, slightly more formal/literary.
- Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri agar saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
untuk – usually “for / to (do something)”.
- With a full clause after it, untuk can sound a bit more formal or written:
- Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri untuk saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi. (acceptable, but a bit heavier)
- More natural is:
- Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri untuk mengetahui bila saya boleh datang lagi.
- With a full clause after it, untuk can sound a bit more formal or written:
For everyday spoken Malay, supaya is very natural here.
In this context, bila means when (as a question word or indirect question):
- ... supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
→ “so that I know when I can come again.”
Differences:
bila
- Common in spoken Malay.
- Used as:
- a question: Bila kamu datang? – When are you coming?
- an indirect question: Saya tidak tahu bila dia datang. – I don’t know when he’s coming.
apabila
- More formal, common in writing.
- Typically used for when in statements, not direct questions:
- Apabila saya sampai, saya akan telefon awak. – When I arrive, I will call you.
In your sentence, bila is perfectly natural and standard. apabila would sound more formal and is less typical in a clause like “so that I know when I can come again”.
Malay usually does not need a separate future marker like will.
- saya boleh datang lagi
literally: “I can come again”
Because of bila (when) and the context (planning a later visit), it is naturally understood as future:
- “when I can come again (in the future)”
If you add akan, it becomes more marked and can sound odd here:
- bila saya akan boleh datang lagi – grammatical but unnatural in everyday speech.
So:
- Tense is mostly inferred from context, time expressions, and words like sudah (already), akan (will), sedang (in the middle of), etc.
- In this sentence, you don’t need akan; the meaning is already clear.
boleh means can / may / be allowed to / be able to.
- bila saya boleh datang lagi
= when I can come again (i.e. when it is possible/allowed/appropriate for me to come again)
If you say:
- bila saya datang lagi
literally: “when I come again”
That sounds more like you are stating a time of a planned action, not asking about possibility or permission. In context:
- bila saya boleh datang lagi – “when I’m able/allowed to come again”
- bila saya datang lagi – “when I do come again”
For asking about which times are possible, boleh is more natural.
lagi has several meanings, but two common ones are:
again (when it comes after a verb)
- datang lagi = come again
- buat lagi = do (it) again
more / another / extra (in other positions)
- lagi satu = one more / another one
- nak makan lagi? = want to eat more?
In your sentence:
- ... bila saya boleh datang lagi.
→ “when I can come again.”
The order datang lagi (verb + lagi) is standard for the “again” meaning.
You could also say datang semula or datang sekali lagi, but datang lagi is the most common, natural choice in everyday speech.
Standard, clear form:
- supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
Here, repeating saya makes the sentence unambiguous and formal/standard.
In informal spoken Malay, people often drop repeated pronouns when context is clear:
- supaya saya tahu bila boleh datang lagi.
- supaya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi. (less common but possible if the subject is obvious)
However:
- In writing or careful speech, keeping both saya is better: it is clearer and more standard.
- For a learner, it’s safer to keep the pronouns until you’re very comfortable with omission in context.
Yes, Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri... sounds polite and reasonably formal, suitable for:
- talking to staff,
- writing an email,
- textbooks and exams.
More casual / everyday alternatives:
- Saya perlukan jadual waktu galeri...
- Saya nak tahu jadual buka galeri, supaya saya tahu bila boleh datang lagi.
- nak (want to) is very common in colloquial speech.
Example very natural spoken version:
- Saya nak jadual buka galeri, supaya saya tahu bila boleh datang lagi.
For learning standard Malay, your original sentence with memerlukan is excellent. Just be aware that in casual speech, people often use nak, drop some pronouns, and simplify phrases.
Yes, that is grammatically correct:
- Supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi, saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri.
Malay allows you to move purpose or time clauses to the front for emphasis. The meaning stays the same.
Differences:
Saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi.
– Neutral order, very natural.Supaya saya tahu bila saya boleh datang lagi, saya memerlukan jadual waktu galeri.
– Slightly more formal/emphatic; it puts more focus on the purpose (“so that I know when I can come again”).
Both are fine; for everyday use, the original order is more common.
A polite, natural spoken version could be:
- Boleh saya dapat jadual buka galeri, supaya saya tahu bila boleh datang lagi?
- Boleh saya dapat... = May I get / Can I have...
- jadual buka galeri = gallery opening schedule
- supaya saya tahu bila boleh datang lagi = so that I know when I can come again
Even shorter and common:
- Boleh bagi saya jadual buka galeri? Saya nak tahu bila boleh datang lagi.
Your original sentence is correct and clear; these versions just sound more like what people actually say in conversation.