Breakdown of Zip itu tidak rosak sejak tukang jahit menjahitnya.
Questions & Answers about Zip itu tidak rosak sejak tukang jahit menjahitnya.
Why is itu placed after zip instead of before it?
In Malay, demonstratives like ini (this) and itu (that/the) usually come after the noun.
So:
- zip itu = that zip / the zip
- buku ini = this book
This is normal Malay word order. English says that zip, but Malay says zip itu.
What does tidak rosak mean literally, and why is there no word for is?
Rosak means broken, damaged, spoiled, not functioning properly.
So tidak rosak means not broken / not damaged.
Malay often does not use a verb like is/are in simple statements like this. So:
- Zip itu tidak rosak literally = That zip not broken
- natural English = That zip is not broken
This is very common in Malay. Adjectives can act like predicates without needing a separate to be verb.
Why is tidak used here and not bukan?
Malay has two common negators:
- tidak: used with verbs and adjectives
- bukan: used mainly with nouns and for identification/equation
Since rosak is functioning like an adjective/state (broken, damaged), the correct negation is:
- tidak rosak = not broken
You would not normally say bukan rosak here.
A quick comparison:
- Dia tidak sakit = He/She is not sick
- Dia bukan doktor = He/She is not a doctor
What exactly does sejak mean in this sentence?
Sejak means since, starting from a point in time or from an event and continuing afterward.
So in this sentence:
- sejak tukang jahit menjahitnya = since the tailor sewed it
This suggests a situation that began after that sewing event and has continued up to the relevant time, usually the present in context.
So the sentence implies something like:
- the zip was sewn by the tailor
- from that time onward, it has not been broken
Why does Malay use tukang jahit for tailor? Isn’t jahit also the verb to sew?
Yes. The root jahit is related to sewing.
- jahit = sew / sewing
- tukang jahit = tailor, seamster/seamstress, sewing worker
Here, tukang often means a person skilled in a certain type of work or trade. So:
- tukang jahit = literally something like sewing worker / sewing specialist
Then the sentence continues with:
- menjahitnya = sewed it
So you see the same root twice:
- tukang jahit = tailor
- menjahit = to sew
That repetition is completely normal in Malay.
What is happening in menjahitnya?
Menjahitnya can be broken down like this:
- meN- = a verb-forming prefix
- jahit = sew
- -nya = it / him / her depending on context
So:
- menjahit = to sew / sewed
- menjahitnya = to sew it / sewed it
In this sentence, -nya refers to zip itu, so it means sewed it.
Malay often attaches object pronouns directly to the verb like this.
Why use -nya instead of a separate word like dia?
Because -nya is a very common attached pronoun in Malay, and here it works naturally as the object it.
So:
- menjahitnya = sewed it
Using dia would usually mean he/she, and it would not fit naturally as the object here in standard usage.
In this sentence, -nya refers back to zip itu. Even though -nya can also mean him/her, the context makes it clear that it means it.
Does this sentence mean the zip is still not broken now?
Usually, yes.
Because of sejak (since), the sentence normally implies continuity from the sewing event up to now or up to the current reference point.
So the idea is:
- the tailor sewed the zip
- from that time until now, it has not been broken
That ongoing meaning comes from sejak plus the context, not from a special tense ending on the verb.
Why is menjahit not marked as past tense if the sewing happened before?
Malay verbs usually do not change form for tense the way English verbs do.
So menjahit can mean:
- sews
- is sewing
- sewed
- has sewn
The time is understood from context or from time expressions like sejak.
In this sentence, sejak makes it clear that the sewing happened earlier, so English translates it with a past form: since the tailor sewed it.
Could rosak mean more than just broken?
Yes. Rosak is a broad word.
Depending on context, it can mean:
- broken
- damaged
- spoiled
- defective
- not working properly
For a zip, tidak rosak most naturally means something like:
- not broken
- not damaged
- still functioning properly
So the exact English wording may vary a little depending on the situation.
Is zip a normal Malay word?
Yes, it is commonly used in Malay, especially in everyday speech, as a borrowing referring to a zipper or zip.
In context:
- zip itu = that zip / that zipper
Malay often uses loanwords alongside native or more formal alternatives, and zip is very natural in ordinary usage.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning MalayMaster Malay — from Zip itu tidak rosak sejak tukang jahit menjahitnya to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions