Breakdown of Proksi diterima kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah.
Questions & Answers about Proksi diterima kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah.
Why is diterima used instead of menerima?
Diterima is the passive form of terima (accept / receive).
- menerima = to accept / accepts in an active sense
- diterima = is accepted / are accepted
So:
- Proksi diterima = The proxy is accepted / Proxies are accepted
This kind of passive wording is very common in formal Malay, especially in rules, procedures, and legal language.
What exactly does proksi mean here?
Proksi means proxy. In formal or legal contexts, it usually refers to a person or authorization acting on someone else’s behalf, such as in meetings, voting, or representation.
In this sentence, it most likely means a proxy appointment or proxy representation is accepted.
Malay often uses loanwords like this in administrative and legal language.
Does proksi here mean singular or plural?
It can be singular or plural, depending on context.
Malay nouns usually do not change form for singular vs. plural the way English nouns do. So:
- proksi diterima could mean the proxy is accepted
- or proxies are accepted
Usually the wider context tells you which one is intended. In legal or procedural writing, English often translates this more naturally as Proxies are accepted...
What does kecuali jika mean, and why are both words needed?
Kecuali jika means except if or more naturally in English, unless.
- kecuali = except
- jika = if
Together they form a conditional exception:
- kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah = unless the mandate is invalid
Malay often uses combinations like this quite naturally. Even though English may prefer one word, unless, Malay commonly expresses it as except if.
Is kecuali jika the same as unless in English?
Yes, in meaning it is very close to unless.
So the whole sentence can be understood as:
- Proksi diterima kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah.
- Proxies are accepted unless the mandate is invalid.
A learner may notice that Malay literally looks more like accepted except if..., but the natural English equivalent is often unless.
What does mandat mean here?
Mandat means mandate, authorization, or authority given to someone.
In this sentence, it likely refers to the legal or formal authorization that supports the proxy. So the idea is:
- the proxy is accepted
- but not if the authorization behind it is invalid
This is a fairly formal word and is common in administrative, political, and legal contexts.
Why is there itu after mandat?
Itu often means that, but in many sentences it also works like a definite marker, making the noun more specific.
So:
- mandat = a mandate / mandate
- mandat itu = that mandate / the mandate in question
In English, you would often translate mandat itu simply as the mandate, not necessarily that mandate, unless the context is pointing to a specific one.
Why is it tidak sah and not bukan sah?
Use tidak before adjectives and verbs, and bukan mainly before nouns.
Here, sah means valid / legitimate, which functions like an adjective. So:
- tidak sah = invalid / not valid
- bukan sah = unnatural / incorrect here
This is a very important Malay pattern:
- tidak besar = not big
- tidak betul = not correct
- tidak sah = not valid
But:
- bukan doktor = not a doctor
- bukan alasan = not an excuse
What does sah mean on its own?
Sah means valid, legal, legitimate, or officially recognized, depending on context.
Examples:
- dokumen sah = a valid document
- perkahwinan sah = a legal/valid marriage
- tidak sah = invalid
In your sentence, mandat itu tidak sah means the mandate is not legally or formally valid.
Is this sentence in a formal style?
Yes, very much so.
Words like proksi, mandat, diterima, and sah all sound formal, administrative, or legal. This is the kind of sentence you might see in:
- meeting rules
- company documents
- election procedures
- legal notices
- official forms
In everyday speech, people might phrase the idea more simply, depending on the situation.
Why doesn’t Malay use the or a like English does?
Malay does not normally have articles like a, an, and the.
So a sentence like:
- Proksi diterima
does not directly show whether English should be:
- A proxy is accepted
- The proxy is accepted
- Proxies are accepted
The context decides that. Sometimes words like itu help make something more definite, as in mandat itu.
This is one of the biggest differences English speakers notice when learning Malay.
Why is the exception placed at the end of the sentence?
That word order is very natural in Malay.
The sentence is built like this:
- Proksi diterima = main statement
- kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah = exception condition
So the structure is:
- [Main rule] + [exception]
This is similar to formal English:
- Proxies are accepted, unless the mandate is invalid.
Malay could sometimes rearrange parts for emphasis, but this order is standard and clear.
Could this sentence be rewritten in a more active way?
Yes. For example:
- Kami menerima proksi kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah.
= We accept proxies unless the mandate is invalid.
This active version uses menerima instead of diterima.
But the original passive version sounds more formal and neutral, which is often preferred in official writing because it focuses on the rule itself rather than on who is doing the accepting.
Is there any ambiguity in what is not valid?
The sentence says clearly that the mandate is what is invalid:
- mandat itu tidak sah = the mandate is invalid
So the proxy itself is being accepted or not accepted, but the reason for non-acceptance is that the mandate behind it is invalid.
In other words:
- the rule is about accepting the proxy
- the condition concerns the validity of the mandate
Can jika be replaced with kalau?
Grammatically, yes, but stylistically it would be less formal.
- jika = more formal if
- kalau = more conversational if
So:
- kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah sounds official and appropriate here
- kecuali kalau mandat itu tidak sah would sound more spoken or less formal
In legal or procedural Malay, jika is usually the better choice.
What is the most natural English way to understand the whole sentence?
The most natural English rendering is:
- Proxies are accepted unless the mandate is invalid.
A more literal breakdown would be:
- Proksi = proxy / proxies
- diterima = is accepted / are accepted
- kecuali jika = except if / unless
- mandat itu = the mandate
- tidak sah = is invalid
So the sentence states a general rule with one exception.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning MalayMaster Malay — from Proksi diterima kecuali jika mandat itu tidak sah to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions