Breakdown of Minit mesyuarat itu berisi persetujuan dan bantahan.
Questions & Answers about Minit mesyuarat itu berisi persetujuan dan bantahan.
Why is it minit mesyuarat and not mesyuarat minit?
In Malay, the main noun usually comes first, and any noun that describes it comes after.
So:
- minit = minutes
- mesyuarat = meeting
That makes minit mesyuarat literally minutes of meeting, which corresponds to meeting minutes in English.
This noun order is very common in Malay:
- buku teks = textbook
- kereta polis = police car
- rumah kayu = wooden house
So minit mesyuarat is the normal Malay order.
What does itu mean here, and why does it come at the end?
Itu usually means that or the one in question.
In Malay, demonstratives like ini and itu normally come after the noun phrase, not before it.
So:
- minit mesyuarat itu = those/the meeting minutes, or that set of meeting minutes
This is different from English, where that comes before the noun.
Compare:
- buku itu = that book / the book
- rumah itu = that house / the house
In this sentence, itu helps make minit mesyuarat definite: it refers to a specific set of minutes.
Is minit singular or plural here?
It can be understood as either minute(s) or minutes, depending on context, but in this expression minit mesyuarat is normally understood as meeting minutes.
Malay nouns usually do not change form for singular and plural the way English nouns do. The same word can often cover both.
So minit does not need an -s ending or anything similar.
If Malay really needs to make plurality very explicit, it can use repetition:
- minit-minit = minutes
But in normal usage, especially in fixed expressions like minit mesyuarat, that is usually unnecessary.
What does berisi mean in this sentence?
Berisi means something like:
- contains
- is filled with
- has as its contents
So Minit mesyuarat itu berisi persetujuan dan bantahan means that the minutes contain agreements and objections.
It is a perfectly natural verb here.
You could think of it as describing the contents of something:
- Kotak itu berisi buku. = The box contains books.
- Laporan itu berisi maklumat penting. = The report contains important information.
What is the role of the prefix ber- in berisi?
The base here is isi, which means contents, content, or fill depending on context.
When it becomes berisi, it functions as a verb/adjectival verb meaning:
- to contain
- to be filled with
- to have contents
The prefix ber- often creates intransitive verbs or verbs describing a state or possession.
In this case, berisi is not usually something you translate word-for-word as ber- + isi. It is best learned as a unit: berisi = contain / be filled with.
Could I use mengandungi instead of berisi?
Yes, often you can.
- Minit mesyuarat itu berisi persetujuan dan bantahan.
- Minit mesyuarat itu mengandungi persetujuan dan bantahan.
Both can mean that the minutes contain those things.
A rough difference is:
- berisi often feels like is filled with / has in it
- mengandungi often feels like contains
Both are natural, but mengandungi can sound a little more straightforwardly formal or factual in some contexts.
Why isn’t there a word for is before berisi?
Because berisi is already the verb.
The sentence structure is:
- Minit mesyuarat itu = subject
- berisi = verb
- persetujuan dan bantahan = object/complement of content
So the sentence already has a predicate. You do not need an extra word meaning is.
English often uses is, but Malay does not always work the same way.
For example:
- Kotak itu berisi barang lama. = The box contains old items.
- Fail itu berisi dokumen sulit. = The file contains confidential documents.
What do persetujuan and bantahan mean exactly?
- persetujuan = agreement, approval, consent
- bantahan = objection, protest, opposition
In the sentence, they refer to the kinds of content found in the minutes: things people agreed to, and things people objected to.
A useful nuance:
- persetujuan can mean a general agreement or approval
- bantahan is an objection or protest
So the phrase suggests the minutes recorded both supportive and opposing responses.
Why do persetujuan and bantahan end in -an?
The ending -an often helps form nouns in Malay, and per-...-an is also a common noun-forming pattern.
Here:
- setuju = agree
- persetujuan = agreement / approval
And:
- bantah = object / protest
- bantahan = objection / protest
This is a very common pattern in Malay, where a root becomes an abstract noun:
- setuju → persetujuan
- bantah → bantahan
- nyata → kenyataan
- lulus → kelulusan
So these are nouns, not verbs.
Are persetujuan and bantahan singular or plural?
Malay often leaves that open unless the context makes it clear.
So:
- persetujuan could mean agreement or agreements
- bantahan could mean objection or objections
In English, the translation might choose singular or plural depending on what sounds most natural in context.
Because the sentence talks about what the minutes contain, English often prefers something plural or collective, such as:
- agreements and objections
- agreement and objection
- records of agreement and objection
Malay itself does not force the distinction here.
Why is there no word for and between minit mesyuarat itu and berisi?
Because berisi is the verb, not another noun in a list.
The sentence is not:
- The meeting minutes and agreement and objection...
It is:
- The meeting minutes
- contain
- agreement and objection
- contain
The only and here is dan, which joins the two nouns:
- persetujuan dan bantahan = agreement(s) and objection(s)
So the structure is completely normal:
Subject + verb + content
Can itu mean the instead of that?
Yes, very often in natural translation.
Although itu literally corresponds to that, in many contexts noun + itu is best translated simply as the + noun when the noun is already identifiable.
So:
- minit mesyuarat itu can be:
- that meeting’s minutes
- those meeting minutes
- the meeting minutes
The best English choice depends on context, but in Malay the form with itu often just marks the noun as specific and known.
Is this sentence formal, neutral, or casual?
It sounds neutral to somewhat formal, which fits the topic.
Words like:
- mesyuarat = meeting
- minit mesyuarat = meeting minutes
- persetujuan
- bantahan
all fit official, administrative, or workplace language.
So this is a natural sentence for office, school, committee, or government contexts.
Could the sentence be rearranged in Malay?
Yes, but the original is straightforward and natural.
A few possible alternatives are:
- Minit mesyuarat itu mengandungi persetujuan dan bantahan.
- Dalam minit mesyuarat itu terdapat persetujuan dan bantahan.
These change the style slightly:
- berisi = contains / is filled with
- mengandungi = contains
- terdapat = there are / there is found
But the original sentence is already correct and natural.
How would a learner naturally break this sentence into chunks?
A very helpful way is:
- Minit mesyuarat itu = the meeting minutes / those meeting minutes
- berisi = contain / are filled with
- persetujuan dan bantahan = agreements and objections
So the whole sentence is:
- Minit mesyuarat itu | berisi | persetujuan dan bantahan.
Chunking it this way makes the grammar much easier to see:
subject | verb | content
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning MalayMaster Malay — from Minit mesyuarat itu berisi persetujuan dan bantahan to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions