Breakdown of Discipulus hanc sententiam recte transferre experitur.
Questions & Answers about Discipulus hanc sententiam recte transferre experitur.
What is the basic grammatical structure of Discipulus hanc sententiam recte transferre experitur?
The core structure is:
- Discipulus = the subject, the student
- experitur = the main finite verb, tries / attempts
- transferre = an infinitive, to translate / to carry across
- hanc sententiam = the object of the infinitive, this sentence
- recte = an adverb, correctly
So the pattern is:
subject + object + adverb + infinitive + main verb
Very literally, it is something like:
The student tries to translate this sentence correctly.
Why is discipulus in the nominative case?
Because it is the subject of the sentence.
- discipulus = nominative singular
- It tells you who is doing the action
Here, the student is the one trying, so discipulus must be nominative.
Why is hanc used here?
Hanc is the feminine accusative singular form of hic, haec, hoc, meaning this.
It has to match sententiam, which is also:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
So:
- hanc = this (feminine accusative singular)
- sententiam = sentence (feminine accusative singular)
They agree because hanc is describing sententiam.
Why is sententiam in the accusative case?
Because it is the direct object of transferre.
The student is trying to translate what?
Answer: hanc sententiam.
Even though transferre is an infinitive, it can still take its own direct object. So sententiam is accusative because it is the thing being translated.
What exactly does sententia mean here?
Here sententia means sentence, as in a sentence of language.
But in other contexts, sententia can also mean things like:
- opinion
- view
- judgment
- thought
So this is a word whose meaning depends a lot on context. In a classroom or translation setting, sententia often means sentence.
Why is transferre an infinitive instead of a normal finite verb?
Because it depends on experitur.
Experitur means tries or attempts, and in Latin verbs like this are commonly followed by an infinitive:
- experitur transferre = tries to translate
So transferre is not the main verb of the sentence. It is the action that the student is trying to do.
What does recte modify?
Recte is an adverb meaning correctly or properly.
It modifies the verbal idea transferre:
- recte transferre = to translate correctly
It tells you how the translating is being done.
What form is experitur?
Experitur is:
- 3rd person singular
- present tense
- indicative mood
It comes from the deponent verb experior, experiri, expertus sum.
So experitur means:
- he tries
- she tries
- the student tries
Here, since the subject is discipulus, it means the student tries.
What is a deponent verb, and why does experitur look passive?
A deponent verb is a verb that has passive-looking forms but an active meaning.
So although experitur looks passive in form, it means:
- not is tried
- but tries or attempts
This is normal for experior and other deponent verbs.
So you should learn experior as a deponent verb from the beginning.
Why is the main verb at the end?
Because Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order.
Placing the finite verb at or near the end is very common in Latin. So:
- Discipulus hanc sententiam recte transferre experitur
is perfectly normal Latin style.
English usually prefers something like:
- The student is trying to translate this sentence correctly
But Latin often saves the main finite verb for the end.
Could the words be arranged differently and still mean the same thing?
Yes, often they could.
For example, Latin could also say things like:
- Hanc sententiam discipulus recte transferre experitur
- Discipulus recte hanc sententiam transferre experitur
The exact emphasis might change a little, but the basic meaning would stay the same because the endings show the grammatical roles.
That said, not every rearrangement is equally natural. The given order is a very normal one.
Is transferre really the verb normally used for translate?
Yes, it can be.
Literally, transferre means to carry across. From that idea, it can also mean to transfer or to translate, depending on context.
In a language-learning context, transferre can mean translate.
So here it makes good sense as:
- to translate this sentence
Why doesn’t Latin use a separate word for to before translate?
Because Latin usually expresses to + verb with a single infinitive form.
So English:
- to translate
becomes Latin:
- transferre
The -re ending here is part of the infinitive form. Latin does not need a separate word like English to.
How would I translate this very literally into English?
A very literal translation would be:
The student tries this sentence correctly to translate.
That sounds unnatural in English, but it helps show the Latin structure.
A better natural English translation is:
The student tries to translate this sentence correctly.
Does hanc mean this in the sense of something near the speaker?
Yes, basically.
Hic, haec, hoc often points to something near, present, or currently in focus. So hanc sententiam means this sentence.
In a classroom context, it could mean:
- this sentence on the page
- this sentence we are discussing
- this sentence right here
So the demonstrative gives a sense of immediacy or nearness.
Could experitur also mean something like tests or experiences?
In other contexts, forms of experior can have meanings like:
- try
- test
- experience
But in this sentence, because it is followed by the infinitive transferre, the meaning is clearly:
- tries
- attempts
So context tells you which English meaning fits best.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Discipulus hanc sententiam recte transferre experitur to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions