Breakdown of Magistra discipulis aliud exemplum ostendit.
Questions & Answers about Magistra discipulis aliud exemplum ostendit.
Why is magistra the subject of the sentence?
Magistra is nominative singular, which is the case normally used for the subject.
It is the feminine singular form of magistra, -ae, meaning teacher. So magistra means the teacher or a teacher, and because it is nominative, it is the one doing the action.
Is magistra specifically feminine?
Yes. Magistra is a feminine noun, so it means a female teacher.
The corresponding masculine form is magister.
Why is discipulis translated as to the students?
Discipulis is dative plural, and the dative case often marks the indirect object—the person to whom something is given, said, or shown.
So here:
- magistra = the teacher
- discipulis = to the students
- aliud exemplum = another example
- ostendit = shows / showed
The teacher is showing the example to the students.
Could discipulis ever be ablative instead of dative?
Yes, the form discipulis can be either dative plural or ablative plural.
But in this sentence, dative makes sense because ostendere commonly takes:
- a direct object: the thing being shown
- an indirect object in the dative: the person it is shown to
So here discipulis is best understood as dative plural.
What case are aliud and exemplum?
They are both accusative singular neuter.
That tells you they go together, with aliud describing exemplum. Together they form the direct object of the verb: the thing being shown.
So aliud exemplum means another example or a different example.
Why is it aliud, not alia or alium?
Because aliud has to agree with exemplum.
Exemplum is:
- neuter
- singular
- accusative
So the adjective must also be:
- neuter
- singular
- accusative
That gives aliud.
A quick comparison:
- alia = feminine nominative singular, or neuter plural
- alium = masculine accusative singular
- aliud = neuter nominative/accusative singular
What kind of noun is exemplum?
Exemplum is a second-declension neuter noun.
That is useful because neuter nouns have an important pattern:
- nominative singular = accusative singular
- both are often in -um
So exemplum could be nominative or accusative by form alone. In this sentence, it is accusative because it is the thing being shown.
How do we know exemplum is not the subject, since its form could also be nominative?
Good question. You figure that out from the whole sentence, not from exemplum alone.
- Magistra is clearly nominative, so it is the natural subject.
- Ostendit is a verb that needs someone who shows something.
- Discipulis fits as the indirect object.
- Aliud exemplum fits as the thing being shown, so it is the direct object.
So even though exemplum could look nominative by itself, the sentence structure shows it is accusative here.
What exactly does ostendit mean here?
Ostendit is the third-person singular active indicative form of ostendere, meaning to show.
Depending on context, ostendit can mean either:
- she shows / he shows / it shows
or - she showed / he showed / it showed
That is because the present and perfect third-person singular forms can look the same in many third-conjugation verbs.
So the exact tense must be decided by context or by the translation already given to the learner.
Why is the verb at the end of the sentence?
Because Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order.
A very common Latin pattern is:
- subject first
- other elements in the middle
- verb last
So Magistra discipulis aliud exemplum ostendit is a very normal Latin order.
Latin uses case endings to show each word’s job, so word order is often used more for style, focus, or emphasis than for basic grammar.
Could the words be put in a different order?
Yes. Because the endings show the grammatical roles, Latin can rearrange the words without changing the core meaning.
For example, these would still mean essentially the same thing:
- Discipulis magistra aliud exemplum ostendit
- Aliud exemplum magistra discipulis ostendit
- Ostendit magistra discipulis aliud exemplum
The difference is mainly one of emphasis or style, not basic meaning.
Why is there no word for the or a in Latin?
Latin does not have articles like English the and a/an.
So:
- magistra can mean the teacher or a teacher
- exemplum can mean the example or an example
You decide from the context which sounds best in English.
Does aliud exemplum mean another example or a different example?
It can mean either, depending on context.
Alius, alia, aliud often has the idea of:
- another
- other
- different
So aliud exemplum could be translated as:
- another example
- a different example
Both are reasonable unless the wider context clearly prefers one.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Magistra discipulis aliud exemplum ostendit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions