Saya sudah makan pagi.

a

Breakdown of Saya sudah makan pagi.

• saya: I
• makan: to eat
• pagi: the morning
• sudah: already

Questions & Answers about Saya sudah makan pagi.

What is the role of sudah in the sentence "Saya sudah makan pagi."?

Sudah indicates that the action of eating has already been completed. It functions similarly to the word “already” or the present perfect structure in English, showing that the meal (breakfast) was eaten before now.

Why is the verb makan used in its base form without any conjugation for past or present tense?

In Indonesian, verbs do not change form to reflect tense. The timing of the action is instead provided by time indicators or auxiliary words like sudah. So makan remains the same regardless of whether the action is ongoing, completed, or habitual.

How does pagi specify the meaning in this sentence?

Pagi literally means “morning” and in this context it indicates the time when the meal was eaten—namely, breakfast. Its placement at the end of the sentence highlights that the eating occurred in the morning.

How does the sentence "Saya sudah makan pagi." compare to saying "I have already eaten breakfast" in English?

The sentence works similarly to the English sentence "I have already eaten breakfast." The use of sudah parallels “already” or the present perfect construction, signifying that the action of eating is complete. The word pagi tells us it was breakfast, corresponding to “breakfast” in English.

Can this sentence be used as a response to the question "Have you eaten breakfast?" and why?

Yes, it can. The sentence confirms the completion of the action by including sudah. When someone asks, "Have you eaten breakfast?" the reply "Saya sudah makan pagi." clearly indicates that breakfast has been consumed.

What would change in meaning if sudah were omitted, resulting in "Saya makan pagi."?

Without sudah, the sentence "Saya makan pagi." loses the emphasis on the completion of the action. While it still means "I eat breakfast" or "I have breakfast," the sense of having already finished the meal is not as strongly conveyed. Sudah is key to understanding that the eating is a completed action.