Breakdown of Entah kontraktor entah mandor, salah satunya harus memeriksa denah.
Questions & Answers about Entah kontraktor entah mandor, salah satunya harus memeriksa denah.
What does the pattern entah ... entah ... do in this sentence?
Entah ... entah ... sets up two alternatives, similar to whether ... or ..., either ... or ..., or sometimes be it ... or ... in English.
So:
- Entah kontraktor entah mandor
= Whether the contractor or the foreman
= Either the contractor or the foreman
It presents two possible people, and the next clause explains what is true about them.
Why is entah repeated twice?
It is normally repeated to mark both options clearly:
- entah A entah B
This is a fixed and very common pattern in Indonesian. Repeating entah makes the pairing sound complete and natural.
So:
- entah kontraktor entah mandor = either the contractor or the foreman
Using only one entah here would sound incomplete or less standard.
Is entah ... entah ... exactly the same as either ... or ... in English?
Not always exactly, but it is very close in many sentences.
In this sentence, entah ... entah ... works much like either ... or .... However, entah can sometimes also carry a nuance of uncertainty, like whether it's X or Y or I don't know if it's X or Y depending on context.
Here, the meaning is basically:
- Either the contractor or the foreman, one of them must check the blueprint.
So for this sentence, either ... or ... is a very good translation.
What does salah satunya mean literally?
Literally, salah satunya means one of them.
Breakdown:
- salah satu = one of
- -nya = the one(s) already being talked about / them
So:
- salah satunya = one of them
In this sentence, the them refers to the two options mentioned earlier:
- kontraktor
- mandor
Why is it salah satunya, not just salah satu?
Because -nya points back to the previously mentioned group.
Compare:
- salah satu = one of [something]
- salah satunya = one of them / one of the ones mentioned
Since the sentence already gives the two choices, adding -nya makes it clear that we mean one of those two people.
Without -nya, the phrase can still sometimes work in other contexts, but here salah satunya sounds more complete and natural.
What does harus mean here?
Harus means must or has to.
So:
- salah satunya harus memeriksa denah = one of them must check the blueprint
It expresses obligation or necessity.
Why is there no word for to before memeriksa?
Because Indonesian does not use a separate word like English to before a verb in this kind of structure.
In English:
- must check
- has to check
In Indonesian:
- harus memeriksa
So memeriksa is simply the verb following harus.
What is the function of me- in memeriksa?
Memeriksa is the active verb form built with the meN- prefix.
Base form:
- periksa = inspect, examine, check
With prefix:
- memeriksa = to inspect / to examine / to check
The meN- prefix commonly forms active verbs in Indonesian. Because the base begins with p, the prefix changes shape and the p drops:
- meN- + periksa → memeriksa
This is a very common sound/spelling change in Indonesian verb formation.
Could periksa be used instead of memeriksa?
In standard formal Indonesian, memeriksa is the expected form here.
- harus memeriksa denah = standard, natural
You may hear periksa used without the prefix in informal speech, commands, headlines, or casual conversation, but in a full neutral sentence like this, memeriksa is better.
What does denah mean exactly?
Denah usually means a plan, layout, or diagram of a space, often something like a floor plan, site plan, or building plan.
Depending on context, it may be translated as:
- blueprint
- plan
- layout drawing
So in this sentence, it refers to a technical drawing or plan that needs to be checked.
Why is there a comma after mandor?
The comma separates the opening alternative phrase from the main clause.
Structure:
- Entah kontraktor entah mandor,
opening setup: the two alternatives - salah satunya harus memeriksa denah.
main statement: what must happen
It works a bit like English punctuation in a sentence such as:
- Whether the contractor or the foreman, one of them must inspect the plan.
The comma helps readability and makes the sentence structure clearer.
Could this sentence be rewritten in a more straightforward way?
Yes. A more direct version would be:
- Kontraktor atau mandor, salah satunya harus memeriksa denah.
- Entah kontraktor atau mandor, salah satunya harus memeriksa denah.
- Salah satu dari kontraktor dan mandor harus memeriksa denah.
These are similar in meaning, but entah ... entah ... has a slightly more patterned, deliberate feel. It sounds a bit like setting up two possibilities before stating the requirement.
Does salah satunya mean exactly one person must do it?
The sentence says that at least one of the two must do it, and it strongly suggests that the responsibility falls on one of them rather than talking about both together.
In normal reading, it means:
- one of the two must inspect the plan
It does not emphasize both doing it. If the meaning were both must inspect it, Indonesian would use something like:
- keduanya harus memeriksa denah = both of them must inspect the plan
So yes, the sentence points to one of the two, not both.
Is the subject of memeriksa really salah satunya?
Yes. In the main clause:
- salah satunya = subject
- harus = modal / must
- memeriksa = verb
- denah = object
So the structure is:
- One of them
- must
- inspect
- the plan
- inspect
- must
The opening phrase Entah kontraktor entah mandor sets up who them refers to.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning IndonesianMaster Indonesian — from Entah kontraktor entah mandor, salah satunya harus memeriksa denah to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions