Breakdown of Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
Questions & Answers about Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
What does van-e mean, and why is -e attached to the verb?
-e is a question particle used in embedded yes/no questions.
So in this sentence:
- Nem tudom = I don’t know
- hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e = whether the library is still open
The -e shows that the clause is a whether/if clause, not a plain statement.
Compare:
- A könyvtár nyitva van. = The library is open.
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár nyitva van-e. = I don’t know whether the library is open.
In English, we use if or whether. In Hungarian, this idea is often shown by -e on the verb.
Why is there both hogy and -e? Don’t they both mean whether/that?
They do different jobs.
- hogy introduces a subordinate clause. It often means that, but in some contexts it can introduce a clause that English would translate with whether.
- -e specifically marks the embedded clause as a yes/no question.
So:
- Nem tudom, hogy... = I don’t know that / I don’t know whether... depending on the rest of the clause
- ...van-e makes it clear that the clause means whether it is...
In practice, in a sentence like this, hogy + -e works together very naturally.
Can hogy be omitted here?
Yes, very often it can.
You can say:
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
- Nem tudom, a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
Both are natural. The version with hogy may sound a little more explicit or formal in some contexts, but both are standard.
Why is it nyitva van and not just nyitott?
Nyitva van is the normal way to say is open in the sense of being in an open state.
- nyitva = open in a state/result sense
- van = is
So nyitva van literally means something like is in an open state.
This pattern is very common in Hungarian:
- zárva van = is closed
- kinyitva van = is opened / has been opened
- becsukva van = is shut
Nyitott also exists, but it is not always interchangeable with nyitva.
For example:
- nyitott ablak = an open window
- A bolt nyitva van. = The shop is open.
For places like shops, offices, libraries, etc., nyitva van is the usual expression.
Why is the word order nyitva van-e instead of van-e nyitva?
In neutral Hungarian, the predicate often appears as:
- nyitva van = is open
That same structure stays together when -e is added:
- nyitva van-e
Hungarian word order is flexible, so other orders can exist in certain contexts, especially for emphasis, but nyitva van-e is the normal neutral form here.
What exactly does még mindig mean? Why are both words needed?
Még mindig means still.
The two words work together:
- még = originally still / yet / more
- mindig = always
But together, még mindig is a fixed expression meaning still.
So:
- a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van = the library is still open
You usually learn még mindig as a chunk.
Why is it a könyvtár and not just könyvtár?
A könyvtár means the library.
Hungarian uses the definite article a / az much like English the.
Since the sentence refers to a specific library, Hungarian normally uses the article:
- a könyvtár = the library
Without the article, könyvtár would sound more like library as a general concept, and it would not fit this sentence naturally.
Why is the sentence Nem tudom... and not Nem tudok...?
Because Hungarian uses tud differently from English know in this structure.
- tudok = I can / I am able to
- tudom = I know it
Here, tud takes a definite object: the whole subordinate clause, understood as a specific thing that is known or not known. That is why the verb appears in the definite conjugation:
- tudom = I know it
- nem tudom = I don’t know it / I don’t know
This is very common with clause objects:
- Tudom, hogy igaz. = I know that it’s true.
- Nem tudom, hogy jön-e. = I don’t know whether he’s coming.
Is Nem tudom, hogy... the most natural way to say I don’t know if/whether...?
Yes, it is very natural.
A very common Hungarian pattern is:
- Nem tudom, hogy ...-e.
For example:
- Nem tudom, hogy igaz-e. = I don’t know whether it’s true.
- Nem tudom, hogy otthon van-e. = I don’t know whether he/she is at home.
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
You may also hear:
- Nem tudom, ...-e
- Nem tudom, vajon ...-e
where vajon adds a sense like I wonder whether.
Could this sentence be written as a direct question instead?
Yes. A direct question would be:
- A könyvtár még mindig nyitva van? = Is the library still open?
That is a normal yes/no question.
But in your sentence, it is not a direct question. It is an embedded question after I don’t know, so Hungarian uses -e:
- ...nyitva van-e
That is one of the main differences between direct and embedded yes/no questions in Hungarian.
Where does the stress or emphasis normally go in this sentence?
In a neutral reading, Hungarian stress usually falls on the first syllable of each word, but sentence-level emphasis depends on what is new or important.
A neutral version is something like:
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
If you want to emphasize still, you might stress még mindig more strongly.
If you want to emphasize the library rather than some other place, you might stress a könyvtár more.
Hungarian uses word order and intonation for emphasis, so the neutral order here does not strongly contrast anything.
Can the sentence order be changed?
Yes, Hungarian word order is flexible, but different orders can sound more marked or emphatic.
Neutral:
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
Possible alternative:
- Nem tudom, hogy még mindig nyitva van-e a könyvtár.
This can also sound natural. It may place the focus a bit differently, depending on context.
So the sentence you have is a normal, standard version, but not the only possible one.
Is -e always attached to van in this kind of sentence?
-e attaches to the element that carries the question marking, often the verb.
Here that is:
- van-e
In other sentences, it may attach to another verb form:
- jön-e = whether he/she is coming
- igaz-e = whether it is true
- lehet-e = whether it is possible
So it is not specifically tied to van; it is tied to the predicate of the embedded yes/no question.
Is the punctuation important here?
Yes. Hungarian normally separates the main clause from the subordinate clause with a comma:
- Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
That comma is standard because hogy a könyvtár... is a subordinate clause.
Even if hogy is omitted, the comma usually remains:
- Nem tudom, a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e.
Can if in English always be translated with -e in Hungarian?
Not always.
English if has two major uses:
whether/if in reported or embedded questions
- I don’t know if he is here.
- Hungarian often uses -e: Nem tudom, itt van-e.
if in conditional sentences
- If it rains, we’ll stay home.
- Hungarian does not use -e for that. It uses words like ha:
- Ha esik, otthon maradunk.
So in your sentence, English if/whether corresponds to the embedded-question pattern with -e, not the conditional ha pattern.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HungarianMaster Hungarian — from Nem tudom, hogy a könyvtár még mindig nyitva van-e to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions