Breakdown of הארון גדול, אבל יש גם מדף קטן מעל השולחן.
Questions & Answers about הארון גדול, אבל יש גם מדף קטן מעל השולחן.
Why is there no separate word for is in הארון גדול?
In Hebrew, simple present-tense sentences often leave out the verb to be. So הארון גדול is literally the cabinet/closet big, but it means the cabinet/closet is big.
This is completely normal Hebrew. English speakers often expect something like הארון הוא גדול, but that is not the neutral everyday way to say it here. The natural sentence is just הארון גדול.
What does יש mean, and why is it used in the second clause?
יש means there is / there are. It is used to say that something exists or is present.
So:
- יש מדף קטן = There is a small shelf
- יש גם מדף קטן = There is also a small shelf
This is different from הארון גדול, which is just describing something.
So:
- הארון גדול = description
- יש מדף קטן = existence/presence
A very useful related word is אין, which means there is no / there are no.
Why do the adjectives come after the nouns in ארון גדול and מדף קטן?
In Hebrew, descriptive adjectives usually come after the noun they describe.
So Hebrew says:
- ארון גדול = literally cabinet big
- מדף קטן = literally shelf small
This is the normal word order in Hebrew. English does the opposite, so this often feels unusual at first.
Why are the adjectives גדול and קטן written in those forms?
Hebrew adjectives must agree with the noun in gender and number.
Here:
- ארון is masculine singular
- מדף is masculine singular
So the adjectives are also masculine singular:
- גדול = big, masculine singular
- קטן = small, masculine singular
If the noun were feminine singular, you would usually get:
- גדולה
- קטנה
For example:
- מנורה גדולה = a big lamp
- קופסה קטנה = a small box
Why do הארון and השולחן have ה־, but מדף does not?
The prefix ה־ is the Hebrew definite article, meaning the.
So:
- הארון = the cabinet/closet
- השולחן = the table
- מדף = a shelf or just shelf, depending on context
Hebrew does not have a separate word for a/an. A noun without ה־ is often indefinite.
So מדף קטן naturally means a small shelf.
Why doesn’t the adjective in מדף קטן also take ה־?
Because the phrase is indefinite: a small shelf, not the small shelf.
In Hebrew, when a noun + adjective phrase is definite, both the noun and the adjective normally take ה־:
- המדף הקטן = the small shelf
But when the phrase is indefinite, neither one takes ה־:
- מדף קטן = a small shelf
This is an important Hebrew pattern.
How would I say the small shelf instead of a small shelf?
You would say המדף הקטן.
Hebrew normally marks definiteness on both parts of a noun-adjective phrase:
- מדף קטן = a small shelf
- המדף הקטן = the small shelf
So if you mean a specific shelf, you usually need ה־ on both the noun and the adjective.
What does גם mean, and why is it placed there?
גם means also, too, or as well.
In יש גם מדף קטן, it means that this small shelf is an additional thing being mentioned:
- יש גם מדף קטן = there is also a small shelf
Its position is natural Hebrew. גם often appears before the word or phrase it is adding emphasis to. Here it helps express the idea of in addition.
What does מעל mean, and how is it different from על?
מעל means above or over.
So:
- מעל השולחן = above the table
This is different from על, which usually means on or on top of, often with contact:
- הספר על השולחן = the book is on the table
- המדף מעל השולחן = the shelf is above the table
So מעל suggests a higher position, not necessarily touching.
Why is it מעל השולחן and not something else?
After מעל, the noun can come directly:
- מעל השולחן = above the table
Since השולחן is definite, it keeps its article ה־. That is completely normal.
Learners sometimes expect Hebrew to change the noun more here, but in this sentence the structure is straightforward: מעל + השולחן.
What does אבל do in the sentence?
אבל means but.
It connects the two parts of the sentence:
- הארון גדול = one statement
- אבל יש גם מדף קטן מעל השולחן = a contrasting or additional statement
So it works very much like English but.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning HebrewMaster Hebrew — from הארון גדול, אבל יש גם מדף קטן מעל השולחן to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions