Breakdown of Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη, όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν.
Questions & Answers about Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη, όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν.
Why does the sentence start with Απορώ? What does it mean here?
Απορώ literally means I am puzzled, I find it hard to understand, or I wonder.
In this sentence, it does not mean that the speaker is asking a direct question. It expresses a feeling of surprise or disbelief:
- Απορώ = I can’t understand / I’m amazed / I wonder
So the speaker is saying that they find the woman’s reaction hard to understand.
Why is πώς used after Απορώ?
Here πώς means how, and it introduces an indirect question:
- Απορώ πώς... = I wonder how... / I can’t understand how...
Greek often uses πώς after verbs like απορώ, βλέπω, ξέρω, θυμάμαι when the speaker is referring to how something happens.
So:
- Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη
= I wonder how she can remain so indifferent
This is different from ότι, which would introduce a statement, not an indirect how-question.
Why is πώς written with an accent?
The accent helps distinguish πώς (how) from πως, which can sometimes mean that in less formal writing.
So here:
- πώς = how
In modern Greek, people do not always make this distinction consistently in casual writing, but in careful writing the accent is useful.
What is μπορεί να μένει doing exactly? Why not just μένει?
μπορεί να often means can, is able to, or sometimes may / might depending on context.
Here:
- μπορεί να μένει = can remain / be able to remain
Using μπορεί adds the idea of amazement that this is even possible:
- Απορώ πώς μένει τόσο αδιάφορη = I wonder how she remains so indifferent
- Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη = I wonder how she can remain so indifferent
The version with μπορεί sounds stronger: the speaker is surprised that such a thing is possible.
Why is it να μένει and not να μείνει?
This is a question of aspect.
- να μένει = imperfective
- να μείνει = perfective
Here μένει describes an ongoing state: remaining, staying indifferent over a period of time.
So:
- να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη = to keep remaining / to stay so indifferent
If you used να μείνει, it would sound more like a single event or a completed reaction: to become/remain indifferent at one point. That is not the main idea here.
Because the sentence describes a continuing attitude while others are worried, the imperfective form μένει is the natural choice.
Why is αδιάφορη feminine?
αδιάφορη is a predicate adjective agreeing with the implied subject, which is she.
Greek adjectives agree in:
- gender
- number
- case
Here the subject is omitted, but understood from context. The sentence is talking about a woman, so the adjective is feminine singular:
- masculine: αδιάφορος
- feminine: αδιάφορη
- neuter: αδιάφορο
So μένει τόσο αδιάφορη means she remains so indifferent.
Why isn’t the word for she actually written?
Greek often drops subject pronouns because the verb form already shows the person and number, and the context gives the rest.
In this sentence, the person being described is understood from context, so Greek does not need to say αυτή.
That is very normal in Greek:
- μένει = she/he stays
- ανησυχούν = they worry / are worried
Greek uses explicit subject pronouns mostly for emphasis, contrast, or clarity.
What does τόσο mean here?
τόσο means so, so much, or to such a degree.
In this sentence:
- τόσο αδιάφορη = so indifferent
It intensifies the adjective αδιάφορη.
Compare:
- αδιάφορη = indifferent
- τόσο αδιάφορη = so indifferent
Is μένει αδιάφορη an idiomatic Greek expression?
Yes. μένω + adjective is a very common Greek pattern meaning remain/stay + adjective.
So:
- μένει αδιάφορη = she remains indifferent
- μένει ήρεμη = she remains calm
- μένει σιωπηλός = he remains silent
This is a normal and natural structure in Greek.
Why does the sentence use όταν here?
όταν means when or while, depending on context.
In this sentence, it is best understood as when / while:
- όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν
= when / while all the others are worried
The idea is that her indifference contrasts with the fact that everyone else is worried at the same time.
So όταν introduces the background situation against which the speaker is reacting.
Why is ανησυχούν in the present tense?
ανησυχούν is present tense because it describes what the others are doing or feeling at that same time:
- ανησυχούν = they are worried / they worry
Greek present tense often covers both:
- a general present
- an ongoing present situation
Here it describes a current, ongoing state: the others are worrying, while she remains indifferent.
What exactly does όλοι οι άλλοι mean?
όλοι οι άλλοι means all the others.
It is made up of:
- όλοι = all
- οι άλλοι = the others
Together they mean everyone else or all the others.
Greek often uses the article with άλλοι:
- οι άλλοι = the others
So the phrase is completely natural.
Why is there a comma before όταν?
The comma separates the main clause from the subordinate clause:
- Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη,
- όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν.
The second clause gives the circumstance or contrast that makes the speaker puzzled.
Greek punctuation often uses commas in places similar to English, especially before a subordinate clause that adds explanatory context like this.
Could the word order be different?
Yes. Greek word order is more flexible than English, though not completely free.
The given order is natural and clear:
- Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη, όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν.
But some parts could move for emphasis. For example, Greek could emphasize τόσο αδιάφορη or όλοι οι άλλοι in other contexts.
Still, the original order is the most neutral and natural for this sentence.
Is ανησυχούν better translated as worry or are worried?
Both can work, depending on how natural you want the English to sound.
- ανησυχούν literally corresponds to they worry / they are worrying
- in natural English here, are worried is often better
So:
- όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν
can be understood as
when everyone else is worried
Greek often uses verbs where English may prefer an adjective or participle-like expression.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GreekMaster Greek — from Απορώ πώς μπορεί να μένει τόσο αδιάφορη, όταν όλοι οι άλλοι ανησυχούν to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions