Breakdown of Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus, mal geben wir sie weiter.
Questions & Answers about Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus, mal geben wir sie weiter.
What does mal ... mal ... mean in this sentence?
Here mal ... mal ... is a fixed pattern meaning sometimes ... sometimes ..., at one time ... at another time ..., or now ... now ....
So:
- Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus
- mal geben wir sie weiter
means that on some occasions we sort clothes out, and on others we pass them on.
This mal is not the same as the casual particle you hear in sentences like Komm mal her.
Why is the word order Mal sortieren wir ... and not Mal wir sortieren ...?
German main clauses normally follow the verb-second rule: the finite verb must be in the second position.
In the first clause, mal takes the first position, so the verb sortieren comes next:
- Mal | sortieren | wir | Kleidung | aus
That is why you get Mal sortieren wir ... rather than Mal wir sortieren ....
The same thing happens in the second clause:
- mal | geben | wir | sie | weiter
Why are aus and weiter at the end?
Because these are separable verbs:
- aussortieren = to sort out
- weitergeben = to pass on
In a main clause, the conjugated part goes in the normal verb position, and the separable prefix moves to the end:
- wir sortieren ... aus
- wir geben ... weiter
This is very common in German:
- anrufen → Ich rufe dich an
- einkaufen → Wir kaufen heute ein
- wegwerfen → Er wirft das weg
Is sortieren ... aus the same as the verb aussortieren?
Yes. sortieren ... aus here is the split form of aussortieren.
The infinitive is:
- aussortieren
But in a normal main clause it becomes:
- Wir sortieren Kleidung aus
In this context, aussortieren means something like to sort out, to remove from a collection, or to set aside because it is no longer wanted/needed.
Why does the sentence use Kleidung and not Kleidungen or die Kleidung?
Kleidung is usually an uncountable noun, like clothing in English.
So German often uses it without an article when speaking in a general sense:
- Wir sortieren Kleidung aus = We sort out clothing / clothes
You would not normally say Kleidungen here.
You can also use an article in other contexts, for example:
- die Kleidung der Kinder
- meine Kleidung
But in this sentence, the general article-less use is completely natural.
What does sie refer to?
Sie refers back to Kleidung.
Grammatically, Kleidung is a singular feminine noun:
- die Kleidung
So the pronoun is:
- sie
Even though English might think of clothes as plural, German is treating Kleidung as a singular mass noun.
So:
- Kleidung → sie
Why is wir repeated in both halves of the sentence?
Because these are two full coordinated clauses, and each clause normally has its own subject:
- Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus
- mal geben wir sie weiter
Repeating wir makes the structure clear and natural.
In English, we also often repeat the subject in this kind of sentence:
- Sometimes we sort clothes out, sometimes we pass them on
Why is there a comma in the sentence?
The comma separates two coordinated main clauses:
- Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus,
- mal geben wir sie weiter.
Each half has its own finite verb and its own subject, so the comma is standard and helpful.
Is the first mal capitalized because it means something special?
No. It is capitalized only because it is the first word of the sentence.
Normally mal is written with a lowercase m:
- mal ... mal ...
At the beginning of a sentence, it becomes:
- Mal ...
Is this mal the same as the shortened form of einmal?
Not really in function.
German mal can come from einmal in some uses, especially in informal speech:
- Komm mal her
- Warte mal
But in mal ... mal ..., it is part of a set expression meaning sometimes ... sometimes .... So it is better to learn this as its own pattern.
Could the sentence also be written with manchmal?
Not in exactly the same way.
You could say something like:
- Manchmal sortieren wir Kleidung aus und manchmal geben wir sie weiter.
That is possible, but mal ... mal ... is shorter and more idiomatic for contrasting alternating actions.
So the original version sounds very natural and elegant:
- Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus, mal geben wir sie weiter.
What is the nuance of weitergeben here?
Weitergeben literally means to give further/on. In this context, it usually means something like:
- to pass on to someone else
- to give away for reuse
- to hand along instead of keeping it
So with clothes, it often suggests donating them, giving them to other people, or otherwise letting someone else use them.
It does not mean simply continue giving here. The idea is passing the clothes on.
Is this sentence formal or informal?
It is neutral and natural German.
It would fit well in everyday speech, an interview, an article, or informational writing. It is not slang, and it is not especially formal either.
The mal ... mal ... pattern is common and idiomatic, so it is a useful structure to learn.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Mal sortieren wir Kleidung aus, mal geben wir sie weiter to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions