Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

Breakdown of Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

sein
to be
wir
we
er
he
behalten
to keep
es sei denn
unless
stark
strongly
der Fotoabzug
the photographic print
vergilbt
yellowed

Questions & Answers about Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

What does es sei denn mean, and how is it used?

Es sei denn means unless or except if. It introduces an exception to what was just said.

In this sentence:

Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

the basic statement is:

Wir behalten den Fotoabzug = We keep the photo print

Then es sei denn adds the exception:

unless it is badly yellowed

So the pattern is often:

Statement + es sei denn + exception

It is a very common fixed expression in German.

Why is it sei and not ist in es sei denn?

This is one of the first things learners notice. Sei is the Konjunktiv I form of sein. In es sei denn, German uses this form as part of a fixed expression.

So although sei may look unusual, in modern German es sei denn is best learned as a whole chunk meaning unless.

Important point:

  • Inside the fixed phrase, it is sei
  • After that, the following clause can still use normal indicative verb forms, as in: es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt

So you do not need to think of the whole sentence as being in a special mood. Just remember:

  • es sei denn = fixed expression
  • the rest of the clause is often normal German
Why is it den Fotoabzug and not der Fotoabzug?

Because Fotoabzug is the direct object of behalten.

The verb behalten means to keep, and what is being kept is the object:

  • Wir behalten was?
    den Fotoabzug

Fotoabzug is a masculine noun:

  • nominative: der Fotoabzug
  • accusative: den Fotoabzug

So:

  • Der Fotoabzug ist neu. = nominative, subject
  • Wir behalten den Fotoabzug. = accusative, direct object
Why does the sentence use er for Fotoabzug?

Because Fotoabzug is a masculine noun, so the matching pronoun is er.

  • der Fotoabzug → er

In the sentence:

..., es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

er means the photo print.

Even though in English we might say it, German pronouns usually follow the grammatical gender of the noun:

  • masculine noun → er
  • feminine noun → sie
  • neuter noun → es
What exactly is a Fotoabzug?

A Fotoabzug is a photo print: a physical printed photograph, not just a digital image or the abstract idea of a photo.

That matters here because a print can become vergilbt over time, meaning it turns yellow with age.

So Fotoabzug is more specific than just Foto in some contexts.

What does vergilbt mean here?

Vergilbt means yellowed or discolored so that it has become yellow, usually because of age, sunlight, bad storage, or paper quality.

It comes from the verb vergilben, meaning to turn yellow.

In this sentence:

  • er ist vergilbt = it is yellowed
  • stark vergilbt = badly / heavily yellowed

So this describes the condition of the photo print.

What is the role of stark in stark vergilbt?

Stark is an adverb here, meaning strongly, badly, or heavily.

So:

  • vergilbt = yellowed
  • stark vergilbt = severely yellowed / badly yellowed

It intensifies the adjective-like participle vergilbt.

Other similar examples:

  • stark beschädigt = badly damaged
  • stark verschmutzt = very dirty / heavily soiled
Why is the word order er ist stark vergilbt and not something with the verb at the end?

Because after es sei denn, German often uses normal main-clause word order.

So you get:

  • es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt

with the finite verb ist in second position in the clause.

Learners sometimes expect subordinate-clause word order everywhere after an expression meaning unless, but es sei denn does not behave exactly like a standard subordinating conjunction such as weil or dass.

You may also see:

  • es sei denn, dass er stark vergilbt ist

That version uses dass, so the verb goes to the end:

  • ... dass er stark vergilbt ist

But the shorter version without dass is very common.

Why is there a comma before es sei denn?

There is a comma because es sei denn introduces an additional clause or clause-like exception.

German punctuation often separates such parts clearly:

  • main statement
  • exception

So: Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.

The comma helps show:

  1. the main statement: We keep the print
  2. the exception: unless it is badly yellowed
Could this sentence also be written with wenn nicht?

Sometimes wenn nicht can express a similar idea, but it is not always as natural or as precise as es sei denn.

For this sentence, es sei denn is the most idiomatic choice for unless.

Compare:

  • Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt.
    = natural, clear exception

A version with wenn nicht would sound more like:

  • Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, wenn er nicht stark vergilbt ist.

That means:

  • We keep the photo print if it is not badly yellowed

This is close in meaning, but the structure is different:

  • es sei denn = state the rule, then add the exception
  • wenn nicht = give a condition directly
Is behalten just to keep, or does it have other meanings?

In this sentence, behalten means to keep or to retain.

That is the most important meaning here:

  • Wir behalten den Fotoabzug = We keep the photo print

But behalten can also be used in other contexts, such as:

  • Darf ich das Buch behalten? = May I keep the book?
  • Ich behalte das im Kopf. = I’ll keep that in mind
  • Sie behielt recht. = less common/literary uses depending on context

For this sentence, the simple meaning keep is exactly right.

What tense is this sentence in?

It is in the present tense.

  • Wir behalten = present tense of behalten
  • er ist = present tense of sein

German often uses the present tense for general rules, habits, or decisions, just as English does:

  • We keep the photo print unless it is badly yellowed.

So this sentence sounds like a general policy or standard practice.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“How do German cases work?”
German has four grammatical cases: nominative (subject), accusative (direct object), dative (indirect object), and genitive (possession). The case determines the form of articles and adjectives. For example, "the dog" is "der Hund" as a subject but "den Hund" as a direct object.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning German

Master German — from Wir behalten den Fotoabzug, es sei denn, er ist stark vergilbt to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions