Breakdown of Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage quand ils viennent.
Questions & Answers about Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage quand ils viennent.
In the sentence Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage quand ils viennent, what does leur mean exactly, and who does it refer to?
Why is it leur apporte and not apporte leur, like in English “brings them”?
What is the difference between leur and les? When would the sentence use les instead?
- leur = indirect object pronoun, meaning to them
- les = direct object pronoun, meaning them
The verb apporter is used like this:
- apporter quelque chose à quelqu’un
(to bring something to someone)
Because of the à quelqu’un, the people are an indirect object, so you need leur.
Compare:
- Marie leur apporte du pain.
Marie brings them bread. (brings bread to them) - Marie les apporte.
Marie brings them. (here “them” would be the things, e.g. the breads/cheeses, as direct objects)
Why is it leur and not eux here?
Leur and eux are different types of pronouns:
leur = unstressed indirect object pronoun (to them)
→ must go before the verb: Marie leur apporte…eux = stressed (disjunctive) pronoun (them for emphasis, after prepositions, alone, etc.)
→ used in positions like:
You can combine them for emphasis:
But on its own before the verb, you must use leur, not eux.
Why is the verb apporte (singular) and not apportent (plural)?
Could we use a different verb instead of apporte, like donne or amène? What is the nuance?
Yes, you could, but the meaning shifts slightly:
apporter = to bring (an object) to someone/somewhere
Focus on movement of a thing toward a place/person.
→ Best choice with du pain et du fromage.donner = to give
Focus on handing something over, not on the movement.
→ Marie leur donne du pain et du fromage = She gives them bread and cheese.amener = to bring (a person or animal)
Normally used for people/animals, not inanimate objects.
→ Marie amène les enfants (Marie brings the children),
but amener du pain sounds odd.
So apporter is the natural, idiomatic choice here.
Why is it du pain and not le pain or just pain without any article?
Similarly, why is it du fromage and not des fromages?
Do we have to repeat du before fromage? Could we say Marie leur apporte du pain et fromage?
In standard French, you should repeat the article:
- ✅ Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage.
- ❌ Marie leur apporte du pain et fromage. (sounds incorrect or very careless)
Each noun in a list normally keeps its own article. Dropping the second du in this case is not considered correct in careful French.
What does quand ils viennent express here? Is it about now, the future, or a general habit?
With the present tense, quand ils viennent expresses a general, repeated habit:
- Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage quand ils viennent.
≈ “Marie brings them bread and cheese when(ever) they come (over).”
It doesn’t describe one specific visit or a single future event, but what usually happens whenever they come.
Why is it ils viennent and not ils viendront after quand?
Could we say quand ils viennent chez elle? Is chez elle implied in the original sentence?
Do leur and ils refer to the same people in this sentence?
Is leur always plural? Could it ever mean to him / to her?
As an indirect object pronoun (the role it has here), leur is only plural and always means to them.
- lui = to him / to her (singular)
- leur = to them (plural)
Example:
- Marie lui apporte du pain. → Marie brings him/her bread.
- Marie leur apporte du pain. → Marie brings them bread.
Note: leur can also be a possessive adjective (leur maison = their house). In that other role it doesn’t show singular/plural for the owners, but that’s a different grammar point. In this sentence, it is clearly the pronoun (so plural).
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Marie leur apporte du pain et du fromage quand ils viennent to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions