Questions & Answers about Personne ne parle dans la salle.
French uses different negative words instead of pas:
- ne ... pas (not)
- ne ... personne (nobody)
- ne ... rien (nothing)
- ne ... jamais (never), etc.
With personne, the pattern is either Personne ne + verb (when personne is the subject) or ne + verb + personne (when it’s the object).
- Subject negative: Personne ne parle.
- Object negative: Je ne vois personne.
The ne always goes before the verb; personne goes where the subject or object would go.
In casual speech, many speakers drop ne:
- Personne parle dans la salle. (informal)
- Very common colloquial variant: Y a personne qui parle (dans la salle).
In writing and careful speech, keep ne: Personne ne parle...
With personne as a negative pronoun, agreement is singular; gender can follow the real referent. Default writing is often masculine:
- Personne n’est venu.
If you know they’re all women, you can write: - Personne n’est venue.
French present can mean both, so add an adverb to clarify:
- Right now: En ce moment, personne ne parle.
- Habitually/ever: Personne ne parle jamais.
Not exactly.
- Personne ne parle dans la salle. = No one is speaking (they might still be present, just silent).
- Il n’y a personne dans la salle. = There is nobody in the room (it’s empty).
Yes. French allows multiple negative words:
- Personne ne dit rien. = Nobody says anything.
For a specific enclosed place with a definite article, use dans + article: dans la salle.
En doesn’t take the article here. Note set phrases like en salle (“indoors,” “in the dining room/service area,” “in theaters” for films) are different.
- salle: a room used for an activity/public space (classroom, meeting room, hall).
- pièce: a room in a house/apartment (generic).
- chambre: bedroom.
So use salle for places like a classroom or meeting room; specify if needed (e.g., salle de classe, salle de réunion).
Before a vowel or mute h, ne becomes n’:
- Personne n’écoute.
Here, parle starts with a consonant, so it stays ne: Personne ne parle.
Use aucun with singular agreement:
- Aucun d’eux ne parle.
Or specify a group: Aucun des étudiants ne parle. (Verb usually singular in careful style.)
Yes, but then it’s a regular noun and needs an article:
- Une personne parle dans la salle. = A person is speaking in the room.
Without ne and without an article, personne does not mean “a person.”