Breakdown of De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
Questions & Answers about De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
What does proefplaatsing mean, and how is that word built?
Proefplaatsing is a compound noun:
- proef = trial / test
- plaatsing = placement
So proefplaatsing literally means trial placement. In context, it is often used for situations like a foster or trial adoption period, especially with animals, but it can also be used more generally for a temporary placement to see whether something works out.
Dutch forms compound nouns very often, much more freely than English.
Why is it de proefplaatsing and not het proefplaatsing?
Why does Dutch use gaat goed here? Why not something like is goed?
Dutch often uses gaan in expressions where English uses to go or sometimes simply to be going well.
- Het gaat goed = It’s going well
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed = The trial placement is going well
So gaan is very natural here.
If you said De proefplaatsing is goed, that would sound more like the placement is good as a general description, not specifically that the process is progressing well.
Why is there no word for it in De proefplaatsing gaat goed?
Because De proefplaatsing itself is the subject.
Compare:
- Het gaat goed. = It is going well.
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed. = The trial placement is going well.
In the second sentence, there is no need for het as a dummy subject, because the real subject is already there: de proefplaatsing.
What exactly does behalve dat mean?
Behalve dat means except that.
So:
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
- The trial placement is going well, except that the dog growls.
This structure is used when one thing is generally true, but there is one exception or problem.
Why is it behalve dat de hond gromt with gromt at the end?
Because dat introduces a subordinate clause, and in Dutch subordinate clauses the conjugated verb usually goes to the end.
- De hond gromt.
Subordinate clause:
- ... dat de hond gromt
This is one of the most important Dutch word-order patterns:
- main clause: verb usually in second position
- subordinate clause: verb goes to the end
Can I also say just behalve de hond or behalve het grommen van de hond? Why is dat needed here?
Yes, but they mean slightly different things.
- behalve
- noun
- behalve de hond = except the dog
- noun
- behalve dat
- clause
- behalve dat de hond gromt = except that the dog growls
- clause
Here the speaker wants to express a whole idea (the dog growls), not just name a thing, so dat is needed to introduce that full clause.
What is gromt? What is the infinitive?
Gromt is the third-person singular present tense of grommen.
Conjugation:
- ik grom
- jij gromt
- hij/zij/de hond gromt
- infinitive: grommen
It means to growl.
So:
- de hond gromt = the dog growls / is growling
How do you pronounce gromt? That final cluster looks difficult.
Yes, gromt can feel awkward for English speakers because of the consonant cluster at the end.
A rough guide:
- grom sounds a bit like English khrom or hrom, depending on how strongly the Dutch g is pronounced in the speaker’s accent
- then add a t at the end: gromt
Important points:
- the Dutch g is not like the English g in go
- the o is short
- the final t is pronounced
If it helps, think of it as:
- grom-men → remove -en → grom
- then add -t → gromt
Why is there a comma before behalve dat?
Because behalve dat de hond gromt is an added subordinate clause giving an exception to the main statement.
Dutch punctuation often uses a comma before this kind of clause, especially when it comes after the main clause and adds extra information.
So the sentence naturally splits into:
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed
- behalve dat de hond gromt
Is behalve dat the same as maar here?
Not exactly.
- maar = but
- behalve dat = except that
Both can contrast two ideas, but behalve dat emphasizes that things are generally fine apart from one exception.
Compare:
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed, maar de hond gromt.
= The trial placement is going well, but the dog growls. - De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
= The trial placement is going well, except that the dog growls.
The second version sounds a little more specific: there is basically one notable problem.
Could this sentence also be said with terwijl or alhoewel?
Not with exactly the same meaning.
- terwijl = while / whereas
- alhoewel = although
- behalve dat = except that
These are different relationships between clauses.
For example:
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed, alhoewel de hond gromt.
This is understandable, but it sounds more like although the dog growls. - De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
This clearly presents the growling as the main exception.
So behalve dat is the best choice if you mean everything is going fine except for this one issue.
Is this a natural sentence in Dutch?
Yes, it is natural and clear.
It sounds like something you might hear in a practical discussion, for example about a dog in a foster home or trial adoption period. The tone is fairly neutral and matter-of-fact.
A few natural alternatives might be:
- De proefplaatsing gaat goed, maar de hond gromt wel.
- De proefplaatsing verloopt goed, behalve dat de hond gromt.
- De proefplaatsing gaat eigenlijk goed; alleen gromt de hond.
But the original sentence is perfectly normal Dutch.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DutchMaster Dutch — from De proefplaatsing gaat goed, behalve dat de hond gromt to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions