Breakdown of De volkstuin is weliswaar klein, maar de grond is goed.
Questions & Answers about De volkstuin is weliswaar klein, maar de grond is goed.
What does volkstuin mean, and how is that word built?
Volkstuin is a compound noun:
- volk = people
- tuin = garden
A volkstuin is an allotment garden or community garden plot: a small piece of land, often rented, where people grow vegetables, flowers, and so on.
Dutch forms compounds very freely, so it is normal to combine nouns like this into one word.
Why do both nouns take de: de volkstuin and de grond?
In Dutch, nouns are assigned a grammatical article, usually de or het.
Here:
- de volkstuin
- de grond
Both of these nouns are common-gender nouns, so they take de.
Unfortunately, there is not always a simple rule that lets you predict whether a noun takes de or het, so learners often need to memorize the article together with the noun.
What does weliswaar mean here?
Weliswaar means something like:
- admittedly
- granted
- it is true that
- to be sure
It introduces a concession: you admit one point before contrasting it with another.
So in this sentence, weliswaar klein means something like admittedly small or small, it is true.
Why do we get weliswaar ... maar ... together?
This is a very common Dutch pairing.
- weliswaar introduces a concession
- maar introduces the contrast that follows
So:
- weliswaar klein, maar ... = admittedly small, but ...
This works a lot like English patterns such as:
- It may be small, but ...
- Although it is small, ...
- Admittedly small, but ...
Dutch often likes to make this contrast explicit with both words.
Why is weliswaar after is instead of before it?
Because Dutch main clauses usually follow the verb-second rule.
In the clause:
- De volkstuin is weliswaar klein
the first element is De volkstuin, and the finite verb is must come second. After that, adverbs like weliswaar can appear.
So this order is normal:
- De volkstuin is weliswaar klein
and not:
- De volkstuin weliswaar is klein
That second version sounds wrong in standard Dutch.
Why are klein and goed not kleine and goede?
Because here the adjectives are used predicatively, not attributively.
Compare:
- de kleine volkstuin = the small allotment garden
- de grond is goed = the soil is good
When the adjective comes before a noun, it often takes -e:
- de kleine tuin
- de goede grond
When the adjective comes after a form of zijn and describes the noun, it usually has no ending:
- de tuin is klein
- de grond is goed
That is exactly what is happening in your sentence.
What does grond mean here? Is it literally ground?
Yes, but in this context grond usually means soil or land, not just the physical ground in a general sense.
In a gardening sentence like this, de grond is goed means the soil is good/fertile/suitable for growing things.
So although the basic translation is ground, the practical meaning here is closer to soil.
Could this sentence also be written with hoewel instead of weliswaar ... maar?
Yes, the idea is very similar, but the structure changes.
For example:
- Hoewel de volkstuin klein is, is de grond goed.
That means the same basic thing: Although the allotment garden is small, the soil is good.
The difference is mainly structural:
- weliswaar ... maar ... uses two coordinated main clauses
- hoewel introduces a subordinate clause, so the word order changes and is moves later in the clause: hoewel de volkstuin klein is
So the meaning is close, but the grammar is different.
Why is there a comma in this sentence?
The comma separates two clauses joined by maar:
- De volkstuin is weliswaar klein
- maar de grond is goed
This is very natural in Dutch, just as in English with but. The comma helps show the contrast between the two parts.
Why is de grond is goed a complete clause instead of just leaving out the second is?
Dutch normally keeps the second clause complete after maar when the structure is:
- clause 1 + maar
- clause 2
So:
- De volkstuin is weliswaar klein, maar de grond is goed.
That is the standard full form.
In some contexts Dutch can omit repeated material, but here the full clause sounds most natural and clear. Since the second subject is different (de grond instead of de volkstuin), keeping is is exactly what you would expect.
Is goed just a general word for good, or does it imply something more specific here?
Here goed is fairly general, but in context it suggests that the soil is:
- fertile
- healthy
- suitable for planting
- productive
So de grond is goed does not just mean the soil is morally good or something abstract like that. In a gardening context, it means the soil is of good quality for growing plants.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DutchMaster Dutch — from De volkstuin is weliswaar klein, maar de grond is goed to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions