Questions & Answers about Jeg skal tømme beholderen.
What does skal mean here?
Skal is a modal verb. In this sentence, it usually means something like:
- have to
- am supposed to
- am going to
The exact nuance depends on context.
So Jeg skal tømme beholderen can suggest:
- an obligation: I have to empty the container
- a plan: I’m going to empty the container
- an instruction or assigned task: I’m supposed to empty the container
It is stronger and more purposeful than just Jeg tømmer beholderen, which usually means I am emptying the container or I empty the container.
Why is there no at before tømme?
Because skal is a modal verb, and in Danish modal verbs are followed by the bare infinitive.
So you say:
- Jeg skal tømme beholderen
- Jeg vil tømme beholderen
- Jeg kan tømme beholderen
Not:
- Jeg skal at tømme beholderen
This is similar to English:
- I can go
- I must leave
not
- I can to go
- I must to leave
By contrast, many other Danish verbs do use at before the infinitive, for example:
- Jeg prøver at tømme beholderen = I’m trying to empty the container
What form is tømme, and how would it change in other sentences?
Tømme is the infinitive form of the verb, meaning the basic dictionary form.
In this sentence it stays in the infinitive because it follows skal.
Some useful forms are:
- infinitive: tømme
- present: tømmer
- past: tømte
- past participle: tømt
Examples:
- Jeg tømmer beholderen = I am emptying / I empty the container
- Jeg tømte beholderen = I emptied the container
- Jeg har tømt beholderen = I have emptied the container
A useful pattern to remember: with a modal verb, the modal changes, not the main verb:
- Jeg skal tømme beholderen
- Jeg skulle tømme beholderen
Why is it beholderen and not a separate word for the?
In Danish, the definite article is often added to the end of the noun.
So:
- en beholder = a container
- beholderen = the container
The ending -en is the definite ending for many common-gender nouns.
This is one of the biggest differences from English. English says:
- the container
Danish usually says:
- container-the in effect, which becomes beholderen
How do I know that it is en beholder and beholderen, not et or -et?
Because beholder is a common-gender noun in Danish.
Danish nouns are mainly either:
- common gender: take en in the indefinite singular and usually -en in the definite singular
- neuter gender: take et in the indefinite singular and usually -et in the definite singular
So:
- en beholder
- beholderen
If it were a neuter noun, it would look more like:
- et hus
- huset
Unfortunately, noun gender usually has to be learned with the noun. A good habit is to memorize nouns together with their article:
- en beholder, not just beholder
When would I say den beholder instead of beholderen?
Beholderen is the normal way to say the container.
Den beholder is not the usual default form for a simple definite noun. You typically use den when:
there is an adjective:
- den store beholder = the big container
you are contrasting or pointing something out:
- den beholder, ikke den anden = that container, not the other one
So if you just mean the container, use:
- beholderen
If you mean the big container, use:
- den store beholder
This is a very common Danish pattern:
- den + adjective + noun
What is the word order in this sentence?
The basic word order here is:
- Jeg = subject
- skal = finite verb
- tømme = infinitive
- beholderen = object
So:
Jeg | skal | tømme | beholderen
The important Danish rule is that in a main clause, the finite verb usually comes in second position.
That is why:
- Jeg skal tømme beholderen
But if you start with another element, the verb still stays second, and the subject moves after it:
- I morgen skal jeg tømme beholderen = Tomorrow I have to empty the container
This is called V2 word order.
A related point: negation usually comes after the finite verb and before the infinitive:
- Jeg skal ikke tømme beholderen = I must not / I’m not going to empty the container
How is this sentence pronounced?
A rough learner-friendly guide would be:
- Jeg: often something like yai or a reduced ya
- skal: roughly sgal
- tømme: TØM-me
- beholderen: roughly be-HOL-der-en
A few important pronunciation notes:
- jeg is often not pronounced exactly the way it looks to an English speaker.
- ø in tømme has no exact English equivalent. It is one of the classic Danish vowels learners need to practice.
- The stress in beholderen is mainly on HOL.
- The ending -en is usually weaker than an English speaker might expect.
So even if your pronunciation is not perfect yet, the main sounds to focus on are:
- jeg
- ø in tømme
- the rhythm of beholderen
Could I replace skal with vil, må, or kan?
Yes, but the meaning changes.
Compare:
- Jeg skal tømme beholderen = I have to / I’m supposed to / I’m going to empty the container
- Jeg vil tømme beholderen = I want to / I will empty the container
- Jeg må tømme beholderen = I must / I am allowed to empty the container
- context decides whether it means obligation or permission
- Jeg kan tømme beholderen = I can empty the container
- Jeg bør tømme beholderen = I should empty the container
So skal is specifically about duty, plan, or expectation, not just desire or ability.
How would I replace beholderen with a pronoun?
You would use den, because beholder is a common-gender noun.
So:
- Jeg skal tømme beholderen becomes
- Jeg skal tømme den
You would not use det, because det is used for neuter nouns.
Compare:
- en beholder → den
- et hus → det
So the gender of the noun affects the pronoun you choose.
How would I say this in the past?
You usually change the modal verb:
- Jeg skulle tømme beholderen
This can mean:
- I had to empty the container
- I was supposed to empty the container
Notice that tømme stays in the infinitive, because it still follows a modal verb.
So the pattern is:
- present: Jeg skal tømme beholderen
- past: Jeg skulle tømme beholderen
If you want to say that the action was actually completed, you might also say:
- Jeg tømte beholderen = I emptied the container
- Jeg har tømt beholderen = I have emptied the container
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DanishMaster Danish — from Jeg skal tømme beholderen to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions