Breakdown of Byl liják, přesto jsme přišli.
Questions & Answers about Byl liják, přesto jsme přišli.
Why is it Byl liják and not Bylo liják?
What exactly does liják mean?
Why doesn’t Czech use a word like English there in there was a downpour?
Czech usually does not need a dummy subject like English there.
English says:
- There was a downpour.
Czech simply says:
- Byl liják.
That is completely natural. Czech often expresses existence or occurrence without any equivalent of English there.
What does přesto mean here?
Why is přesto used instead of ale?
Because přesto expresses a stronger idea of despite that fact.
Compare:
- ale = but
- přesto = nevertheless / even so / despite that
So přesto fits well when the second clause happened in spite of the first one.
Very roughly:
- Byl liják, ale přišli jsme. = There was a downpour, but we came.
- Byl liják, přesto jsme přišli. = There was a downpour; nevertheless, we came.
The second version sounds a bit more explicit and emphatic.
Why is it jsme přišli and not my jsme přišli?
Because Czech often omits subject pronouns when they are not needed.
The verb already tells you the person:
So my (we) is unnecessary unless you want emphasis or contrast.
Compare:
- Jsme přišli. = We came.
- My jsme přišli. = We came. / As for us, we came.
In your sentence, the neutral version without my is the most natural.
Why is the word order přesto jsme přišli and not přesto přišli jsme?
Because jsme is a clitic, and Czech clitics usually go in the second position of the clause.
In the clause:
přesto takes the first position, so jsme naturally comes right after it.
That is why this order is standard and natural.
- Přesto jsme přišli. = natural
- Přesto přišli jsme. = unnatural in normal speech
Czech word order is flexible, but clitics follow special placement rules.
Why is it přišli? What does that form tell us?
Přišli is the past active participle used to form the past tense with jsme.
It tells you two things here:
- past tense
- plural masculine personal / mixed-gender group
So:
- jsme přišli = we came
If the group were entirely female, it would be:
- Byl liják, přesto jsme přišly.
So the ending -i in přišli usually shows a group containing at least one male, or a mixed group.
Why is přišli used instead of something like chodili or přicházeli?
Because přišli comes from přijít, which is perfective. It expresses a completed event: we arrived / we came.
That fits the meaning here: despite the downpour, the action was completed.
Compare:
- přišli = we came / we arrived once, successfully
- přicházeli = we were coming / used to come / were in the process of coming
- chodili = we used to go / used to come regularly
So přišli is the natural choice for a single finished action.
Is the comma necessary in Byl liják, přesto jsme přišli?
Yes, the comma is natural and standard here.
You have two finite clauses:
They are joined in a contrastive relationship, so the comma is used.
In English you might also use a semicolon or a conjunction, but in Czech the comma is standard in this kind of sentence.
Could a Czech speaker also say this in a different way?
Yes. Several alternatives are possible, depending on style and emphasis. For example:
- Byl liják, ale přišli jsme. = There was a downpour, but we came.
- I přes liják jsme přišli. = We came despite the downpour.
- Přestože byl liják, přišli jsme. = Although there was a downpour, we came.
- Pršelo, přesto jsme přišli. = It was raining, nevertheless we came.
Your original sentence is correct and natural; it just has a slightly more formal or written feel because of přesto.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CzechMaster Czech — from Byl liják, přesto jsme přišli to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions