Breakdown of Částka je správná, položka je však chybná.
Questions & Answers about Částka je správná, položka je však chybná.
Why do správná and chybná end in -á?
Because Czech adjectives must agree with the noun they describe in gender, number, and case.
Here:
So the adjectives must also be feminine singular nominative:
- správná for částka
- chybná for položka
Compare:
- správný = masculine
- správná = feminine
- správné = neuter
Even though the adjectives come after je, they still agree with the subject.
What case are částka and položka in?
What is the role of však here?
Však adds contrast. In this sentence it means something like however, though, or but.
So the logic is:
- The amount is correct
- the item, however, is incorrect
It signals that the second clause contrasts with the first one.
A very natural English equivalent would be:
- The amount is correct, but the item is incorrect
- or The amount is correct; however, the item is incorrect
How is však different from ale?
Both can express contrast, but they are not used in exactly the same way.
- ale = the most common plain but
- však = often a bit more formal, written, or stylistically polished; often closer to however / though
So:
Částka je správná, ale položka je chybná.
= very straightforward, very commonČástka je správná, položka je však chybná.
= slightly more formal or elegant
Both are correct. A learner will probably hear ale more often in everyday speech.
Why is však placed after je instead of directly after položka?
Czech word order is relatively flexible, and však often appears early in the clause, but not always in exactly the same spot.
In this sentence:
- položka je však chybná
this placement is natural and idiomatic.
You may also encounter other placements in real Czech depending on style and emphasis, but for learners it is best to treat je však as a normal pattern in sentences like this.
The main thing to remember is:
- však usually does not behave exactly like English however
- you should not try to translate its position word-for-word from English
So learn the whole chunk:
- je však
as a common way to express is, however, ...
Why is there a comma in the sentence?
Because the sentence contains two main clauses:
Czech normally separates such clauses with a comma, especially when there is a contrast between them.
So the comma marks the division between:
- first statement
- contrasting second statement
This is similar to English punctuation in a sentence like:
- The amount is correct, but the item is incorrect.
Could I also say Částka je správná, ale položka je chybná?
Yes, absolutely.
That version is probably the more obvious one for a learner, and it is very natural Czech.
The difference is mainly stylistic:
- ale = more everyday, direct
- však = a bit more formal or literary in feel
So both are correct:
- Částka je správná, ale položka je chybná.
- Částka je správná, položka je však chybná.
If you are unsure, ale is often the safer choice in conversation.
Why is chybná used instead of something like špatná?
Because chybný means incorrect, erroneous, containing an error, which fits very well in technical, administrative, or formal contexts.
By contrast, špatný / špatná is broader and can mean:
- bad
- poor
- wrong
- unsuitable
So here:
- chybná položka sounds more precise: the item is incorrect / entered wrongly / in error
- špatná položka could sound more general: the item is bad or wrong in a less exact way
In documents, accounting, forms, and similar contexts, chybný is often the better word.
Do Czech nouns here need articles like the amount or the item?
No. Czech has no articles like a, an, or the.
So:
- částka can mean an amount, the amount
- položka can mean an item, the item, a line item
The exact meaning depends on context.
That is why a single Czech sentence can be translated into English in more than one natural way, depending on what the situation is.
How do I pronounce the trickier words in this sentence?
A few useful points:
- Czech stress is normally on the first syllable of the word.
- č sounds like ch in church
- ž sounds like the s in measure
- ch is one sound, like Scottish loch or German Bach, not English ch
Rough pronunciation help:
- Částka ≈ CHAAS-tka
- správná ≈ SPRAAV-naa
- položka ≈ PO-lozh-ka
- však ≈ vshak
- chybná ≈ KHIB-naa or KHYB-naa depending on how you approximate ch
Also remember that á is a long vowel, so:
- správná
- chybná
both have a long final -á sound.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CzechMaster Czech — from Částka je správná, položka je však chybná to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions