Breakdown of Quina opinió tens sobre aquest article?
Questions & Answers about Quina opinió tens sobre aquest article?
Why does the sentence start with quina?
Quina means what or more literally which, and it agrees with opinió, which is a feminine singular noun.
So:
- quin = masculine singular
- quina = feminine singular
- quins = masculine plural
- quines = feminine plural
Because opinió is feminine singular, Catalan uses quina opinió.
Why is it quina opinió instead of just què opinió?
In Catalan, què and quin/quina are used differently.
- què = what, used on its own
- quin/quina = which/what kind of, used before a noun
Since opinió is a noun, Catalan uses quina before it:
- Quina opinió tens...? = What opinion do you have...?
- Què penses...? = What do you think...?
English often uses what in both cases, but Catalan makes a distinction here.
What does tens mean, and why is it used here?
Tens is the 2nd person singular form of tenir, meaning to have.
- jo tinc = I have
- tu tens = you have
- ell/ella té = he/she has
So Quina opinió tens...? literally means What opinion do you have...?
This sounds natural in Catalan, even though English would more often say What do you think...?
Is this sentence informal or formal?
It is informal singular, because it uses tens, the form for tu.
If you wanted to address someone formally, you would usually say:
- Quina opinió té sobre aquest article?
Here té is the vostè form.
So:
- tens = informal you
- té = formal you
Why is the word order Quina opinió tens... and not something else?
This is normal Catalan question word order.
A common pattern is:
Question word + noun + verb + rest
So:
- Quina opinió = what opinion
- tens = do you have
- sobre aquest article = about this article
Unlike English, Catalan does not need do in questions here.
English says What opinion do you have...?, but Catalan simply says Quina opinió tens...?
What does sobre mean here?
Sobre here means about or regarding.
So:
- sobre aquest article = about this article
It is a very common preposition in Catalan when talking about a topic:
- un llibre sobre història = a book about history
- parlar sobre política = to talk about politics
In everyday speech, other structures are also possible, but sobre is perfectly natural here.
Why is it aquest article?
Aquest means this and must agree with the noun it describes.
Since article is masculine singular, Catalan uses aquest.
Here is the pattern:
- aquest = this, masculine singular
- aquesta = this, feminine singular
- aquests = these, masculine plural
- aquestes = these, feminine plural
Examples:
- aquest article = this article
- aquesta revista = this magazine
Does article in Catalan mean the same as in English?
Yes, in this context article means article, as in a newspaper, magazine, or online article.
Be aware that Catalan article can also mean grammatical article in grammar discussions, just like English article.
In this sentence, though, it clearly means a written piece.
How is opinió pronounced, and why does it have an accent?
Opinió is pronounced roughly like oh-pee-nee-O, with the stress on the final syllable.
The written accent ó shows where the stress falls. Without the accent, the stress pattern would be different.
A rough breakdown:
- o-pi-ni-Ó
The accent is important because Catalan spelling often marks irregular stress.
Is there a more natural or common way to say this in Catalan?
Yes. This sentence is correct, but many speakers would also say:
- Què en penses d'aquest article?
That means What do you think of this article?
Both are natural, but they feel slightly different:
- Quina opinió tens sobre aquest article? = a bit more explicit, somewhat more formal or careful
- Què en penses d'aquest article? = very common and conversational
So the original sentence is good Catalan, but it is useful to know the alternative too.
Can I translate it word for word into English?
You can translate it literally as:
- What opinion do you have about this article?
That is understandable English, but the most natural English version is usually:
- What do you think about this article?
- What’s your opinion on this article?
So the Catalan structure is slightly closer to What opinion do you have...?, even though English often prefers a different phrasing.
Why is there no article before opinió?
Catalan does not need an article here because quina already introduces the noun.
Compare:
- quina opinió = what opinion
- not quina l'opinió
This is similar to English, where you say what opinion, not what the opinion.
So quina is doing the job of introducing the noun phrase.
How would I pronounce the whole sentence?
A rough pronunciation guide is:
KEE-nuh oh-pee-nee-O tens SOH-bruh ah-KEST ar-TEE-kluh?
A few notes:
- Quina sounds roughly like KEE-nuh
- tens has a short e
- aquest ends with a clear t
- article is not pronounced exactly like English article
Pronunciation varies somewhat by dialect, but this approximation is good enough for a learner to start with.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Quina opinió tens sobre aquest article to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions