Breakdown of Hi ha un paper amb la resposta al costat de l'ordinador.
Questions & Answers about Hi ha un paper amb la resposta al costat de l'ordinador.
What does hi ha mean, and why are there two words?
Hi ha is the standard Catalan way to say there is or there are.
- ha comes from the verb haver
- hi is a little adverb-like element that is part of this expression
So:
- Hi ha un paper = There is a sheet of paper
- Hi ha dos papers = There are two sheets of paper
Even though English changes between there is and there are, Catalan normally keeps hi ha for both singular and plural.
Why is it un paper and not una paper?
Because paper is a masculine noun in Catalan.
So the indefinite article is:
- un for masculine singular
- una for feminine singular
Examples:
- un paper
- una resposta
This is why the sentence has un paper but later la resposta.
Does paper mean paper in general, or a sheet of paper here?
In this sentence, un paper usually means a piece/sheet of paper or a paper/note, not the material in an abstract sense.
So depending on context, it could suggest:
- a sheet of paper
- a note
- a document
If you were talking about paper as a material in general, Catalan can also use paper, but the context would make that clear.
Why is it amb la resposta and not something like amb resposta?
La resposta means the answer, referring to a specific answer.
Catalan often uses the definite article where English also uses it:
- amb la resposta = with the answer
If you said amb resposta, it would sound incomplete or unusual here, because it would mean something more like with answer rather than with the answer.
What does amb mean, and can it also mean and?
Here amb means with.
- un paper amb la resposta = a paper with the answer
It does not mean and in standard Catalan.
A learner might confuse it with Spanish ambos or with other small connecting words, but in Catalan amb is a preposition meaning with.
What does al costat de mean exactly?
Al costat de means next to, beside, or at the side of.
In this sentence:
- al costat de l'ordinador = next to the computer
It is a fixed expression:
- costat = side
- de = of
- al = a + el = to the / at the
Literally, it is something like at the side of the computer, but in natural English we usually say next to the computer.
Why is it al costat de but then de l'ordinador?
Because two different grammar things are happening:
al is a contraction of a + el
- a el costat becomes al costat
l'ordinador is the article el shortened before a vowel
- el ordinador becomes l'ordinador
So:
- al costat de l'ordinador
breaks down as:
- a + el costat
- de + l'ordinador
This is very common in Catalan.
Why does ordinador become l'ordinador?
Because ordinador begins with a vowel, and the masculine singular article el is usually shortened to l' before a vowel sound.
So:
- el llibre
- l'ordinador
- l'amic
This is similar to how French shortens articles before vowels.
Is the word order normal in Catalan?
Yes, it is completely normal.
The structure is:
- Hi ha = there is
- un paper = a paper
- amb la resposta = with the answer
- al costat de l'ordinador = next to the computer
Catalan often puts descriptive phrases after the noun:
- un paper amb la resposta
- un home amb ulleres
- una noia de Barcelona
So the sentence flows in a very natural Catalan order.
Could I also say Hi ha la resposta en un paper...?
Yes, but it would mean something slightly different in focus.
- Hi ha un paper amb la resposta... focuses first on the paper
- Hi ha la resposta en un paper... focuses more on the answer
The original sentence is more natural if you are pointing out the existence of a paper/note that has the answer on it.
How would this sentence change in the plural?
You would make the noun phrase plural, but hi ha usually stays the same.
Examples:
- Hi ha uns papers al costat de l'ordinador.
- Hi ha dos papers amb les respostes al costat de l'ordinador.
Notice:
- un paper → uns papers
- la resposta → les respostes
- hi ha stays hi ha
How is Hi ha un paper amb la resposta al costat de l'ordinador pronounced?
A careful approximate pronunciation is:
ee AH oom puh-PAYR ahm lah rəs-PO-stuh ahl koo-STAT duh lur-dee-nuh-DOHR
A few useful notes:
- hi ha sounds roughly like ee AH
- paper in Catalan is stressed on the second syllable: pa-PER
- resposta has stress on pos
- costat has stress on the last syllable
- ordinador has stress on the last syllable: or-di-na-DOR
Exact pronunciation varies a bit by dialect, but this will help you recognize the sentence.
What are the main grammar points a learner should notice in this sentence?
A native English speaker should especially notice these:
- hi ha = there is / there are
- noun gender:
- un paper masculine
- la resposta feminine
- amb = with
- al costat de = next to
- article changes:
- a + el = al
- el + ordinador = l'ordinador
So this one sentence is useful because it combines:
- existence (hi ha)
- articles
- gender
- a common prepositional expression
- contractions and elision
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Hi ha un paper amb la resposta al costat de l'ordinador to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions