Questions & Answers about في الممر فيه رف صغير حطينا عليه المفاتيح.
They are doing two different jobs here:
- في الممر = in the hallway
- Here في is the normal preposition in.
- فيه رف صغير = there is a small shelf
- Here فيه is part of an existential expression, meaning there is / there are.
So even though they look related, they are not being used the same way in this sentence.
A learner might expect فيه to mean in it, and sometimes it does in other contexts. But here, in Egyptian Arabic, فيه often works like there is.
Because Arabic often starts with a place or time phrase to set the scene first.
So:
- في الممر = in the hallway
- then the speaker says what is there: فيه رف صغير
This is very natural in Egyptian Arabic, just like English can say:
- In the hallway, there’s a small shelf.
It gives the location first, then the new information.