Breakdown of Haar serp is nie so lank soos myne nie, maar dit is sagter.
Questions & Answers about Haar serp is nie so lank soos myne nie, maar dit is sagter.
Why are there two nie's in Haar serp is nie so lank soos myne nie?
Afrikaans often uses a double negative structure.
In this sentence, the pattern is:
nie so ... soos ... nie = not as ... as ...
So:
- nie after the verb introduces the negation
- the final nie closes it
That is completely normal Afrikaans grammar.
Examples:
- Hy is nie so oud soos ek nie. = He is not as old as I am.
- Dit is nie maklik nie. = It is not easy.
So the two nie's are not two separate negatives in the English sense. They are one standard Afrikaans negative frame.
How does nie so ... soos ... nie work?
This is the Afrikaans way to say not as ... as.
The pattern is:
nie so + adjective + soos + noun/pronoun + nie
In your sentence:
- nie so lank soos myne nie
- literally: not so long as mine
- natural English: not as long as mine
More examples:
- Sy is nie so vinnig soos haar broer nie. = She is not as fast as her brother.
- Die huis is nie so groot soos ons s'n nie. = The house is not as big as ours.
So so ... soos is the comparison pattern, and the two nie's make it negative.
Why is it myne and not my?
My means my before a noun:
- my serp = my scarf
But when the noun is left out, Afrikaans often uses the independent possessive pronoun:
- myne = mine
So:
- my serp = my scarf
- die serp is myne = the scarf is mine
In this sentence, myne stands for my scarf:
- Haar serp is nie so lank soos myne nie
- = Her scarf is not as long as mine
This is similar to English my vs mine.
What exactly does haar mean here?
Here, haar means her.
So:
- haar serp = her scarf
Afrikaans haar can be used as a possessive determiner, like English her before a noun.
Examples:
- haar boek = her book
- haar jas = her coat
It is not changing form here; Afrikaans does not do the same kind of adjective agreement that English learners may expect from some other languages.
Why is the second part dit is sagter and not something with sy or hy?
Afrikaans commonly uses dit to refer back to things, including objects like serp.
So:
- dit = it
In the sentence:
- maar dit is sagter
- = but it is softer
Even though serp is a noun, Afrikaans does not assign grammatical gender in the same way that languages like German do. For ordinary objects, dit is the normal pronoun.
How is sagter formed?
Sagter is the comparative form of sag.
- sag = soft
- sagter = softer
A very common way to form the comparative in Afrikaans is:
adjective + -er
Examples:
- lank → langer = long → longer
- sag → sagter = soft → softer
- oud → ouer = old → older
So dit is sagter simply means it is softer.
Why is there no word for than in dit is sagter?
Because the comparison is only implied by the context.
The full idea is:
- Her scarf is not as long as mine, but it is softer.
In the second clause, Afrikaans just says:
- maar dit is sagter
- but it is softer
You do not need as or than there, because the listener already understands that the scarf is being compared with mine.
If you wanted to state the comparison more explicitly in another sentence, Afrikaans would use as with a comparative:
- Dit is sagter as myne. = It is softer than mine.
Why is lank used for a scarf?
Lank means long in the sense of physical length.
That makes sense for a scarf, because a scarf has measurable length.
Examples:
- 'n lang serp = a long scarf
- 'n lang tou = a long rope
So nie so lank soos myne nie is exactly the kind of phrase you would expect for comparing two scarves.
Is the word order after maar anything special?
No, it is just standard Afrikaans main-clause word order.
- maar = but
- dit is sagter = it is softer
Afrikaans main clauses usually keep the verb in the second position:
- Dit is sagter.
- Maar dit is sagter.
So after maar, the clause continues normally.
Could I also say Haar serp is nie so lank as myne nie?
The standard pattern for equality comparison is so ... soos:
- so lank soos myne
That is the form learners should use confidently.
You may sometimes see or hear variation in informal language, but soos is the normal and safest choice here. For learning purposes, treat:
- so ... soos = as ... as
as the standard rule.
Why is there no extra ending on lank or sagter?
In this sentence, both adjectives are being used predicatively, meaning they come after is:
- is ... lank
- is ... sagter
Predicative adjectives in Afrikaans usually do not take the extra adjective ending that learners may see in other contexts.
Compare:
- Die serp is lank. = The scarf is long.
- Die serp is sagter. = The scarf is softer.
So the forms here are normal because the adjectives come after the verb, not directly before a noun.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Haar serp is nie so lank soos myne nie, maar dit is sagter to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions