Breakdown of Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie.
Questions & Answers about Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie.
Why does Afrikaans use nie twice in this sentence?
This is one of the most important features of Afrikaans negation.
In a basic negative sentence, Afrikaans usually uses double negation:
- the first nie comes after the verb or the element being negated
- the second nie usually comes at the end of the clause
So:
In this sentence:
- Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie.
the first nie follows weet and the second nie closes the sentence.
This pattern is very normal in Afrikaans.
Why is the sentence not Ek weet die rede vir haar vraag nie?
What is the difference between weet and ken? Why is weet used here?
Afrikaans has two common verbs that can both relate to knowing, but they are used differently:
- weet = to know a fact, piece of information, answer, reason, truth, etc.
- ken = to know a person, place, or be familiar with something
Here, the speaker is talking about knowing the reason for something, so weet is correct.
Examples:
- Ek weet die antwoord. = I know the answer.
- Ek ken haar. = I know her.
So:
- Ek weet nie die rede ... nie is correct because a reason is information, not a person or place.
Why is it die rede and not 'n rede?
Why is vir used in die rede vir haar vraag?
Here vir means for.
So:
- die rede vir haar vraag = the reason for her question
This is a very common pattern:
- die rede vir die probleem = the reason for the problem
- die rede vir sy vertrek = the reason for his departure
English speakers sometimes expect other prepositions, but with rede, vir is the normal choice when you mean reason for.
Why is it haar vraag and not sy vraag?
Is vraag here a verb or a noun?
What is the basic word order of this sentence?
The sentence follows normal Afrikaans main-clause order:
- Ek = subject
- weet = verb
- nie = first negative marker
- die rede vir haar vraag = object / rest of the sentence
- nie = final negative marker
So the pattern is:
- Subject + verb + nie + object/complement + nie
That gives:
- Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie.
Could this also be said in a more natural or conversational way?
Yes. The sentence is correct, but in everyday speech Afrikaans speakers might often say something like:
- Ek weet nie hoekom sy vra nie. = I do not know why she is asking.
- Ek weet nie hoekom sy gevra het nie. = I do not know why she asked.
Your original sentence is a bit more formal or abstract because it uses die rede vir haar vraag.
So:
- Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie. = correct, slightly more formal/book-like
- Ek weet nie hoekom sy vra nie. = very natural in conversation
Can vraag mean both question and request?
Yes, sometimes it can, depending on context.
Most often:
- vraag = question
But in some contexts it can also mean a request or demand. In this sentence, though, the meaning is clearly question, especially because of the structure die rede vir haar vraag.
A learner should usually understand vraag first as question, unless the context shows otherwise.
How would this sentence sound if I wanted to emphasize that I really do not know?
You could add emphasis in a few ways, for example:
- Ek weet regtig nie die rede vir haar vraag nie. = I really do not know the reason for her question.
- Ek weet glad nie die rede vir haar vraag nie. = I absolutely do not know the reason for her question.
Here:
- regtig = really
- glad nie = not at all
Both are common ways to strengthen the negative.
How is rede pronounced, and is it related to English reason?
Yes, rede means reason, and the words are related historically.
A rough pronunciation guide is:
- rede ≈ REE-duh
The first syllable is stressed.
The final e is a schwa-like sound, similar to the a in English sofa.
So if you are reading the sentence aloud, a rough English approximation would be:
- Ek vate nee dee REE-duh feer haar fraakh nee
That is only approximate, but it can help at first.
Could I replace die rede with hoekom in the same sentence?
Not directly in the exact same structure, because hoekom means why, so it changes the grammar.
- Ek weet nie hoekom vir haar vraag nie. ✗
Instead, you would build a different sentence, such as:
So:
- die rede vir haar vraag = the reason for her question
- hoekom sy vra = why she is asking
They express similar ideas, but with different grammar.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Ek weet nie die rede vir haar vraag nie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions