Breakdown of Er gibt dem Fan, einem kleinen Mädchen, das Autogramm.
ein
a, an (eine)
er
he
klein
small
das Mädchen
the girl
geben
to give
der Fan
the fan
das Autogramm
the autograph
Questions & Answers about Er gibt dem Fan, einem kleinen Mädchen, das Autogramm.
Why is the phrase einem kleinen Mädchen in the dative case?
This phrase is a noun apposition, meaning it sits directly next to another noun to describe it. An apposition always copies the case of the noun it refers to. Because dem Fan is the indirect object (the receiver of the autograph) and takes the dative case, the apposition describing the fan must also be in the dative case.
Why is das Autogramm not in the dative case like the fan and the girl?
das Autogramm is the direct object of the sentence because it is the actual item being given. Direct objects always take the accusative case. The fan and the girl represent the indirect object (the receiver of the item), which is why they take the dative case.
Why do we use the neuter article einem for a girl?
Grammatical rules override biological gender in German. Any noun ending in the diminutive suffix -chen is automatically neuter. Since Mädchen is a neuter noun and needs to be in the dative case here, we use the neuter article einem instead of a feminine article.
Why does the adjective kleinen end in -en?
This is a standard rule for adjective endings. Whenever an adjective follows a dative article like einem, it always takes the -en suffix, regardless of whether the noun is masculine, feminine, or neuter.
Why are there commas around einem kleinen Mädchen?
An apposition acts like an extra, parenthetical thought that interrupts the sentence to clarify who the fan is. In German grammar, this extra description must be set off by commas to separate it clearly from the core parts of the sentence.
Learn Er gibt dem Fan, einem kleinen Mädchen, das Autogramm and more in German
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free