Log inSign up

Est-ce que tu lui mens souvent ?

Est-ce que tu lui mens souvent ?
Do you often lie to him?
From Lesson 106:Indirect object pronouns (lui, leur)·French

Questions & Answers about Est-ce que tu lui mens souvent ?

Why do we use lui here instead of a direct object pronoun like le?
In French, the verb is mentir à (to lie to someone). Because of that à, the person receiving the action is an indirect object. We use lui to replace à plus a single person.
Does lui mean "to him" or "to her" in this sentence?
It can mean either one! As an indirect object pronoun, lui is used for both masculine and feminine people. Depending on the conversation's context, this sentence could just as easily mean "Do you often lie to her?".
Why is lui placed before the verb mens?
In French, object pronouns almost always go directly before the verb they belong to. Instead of putting the pronoun at the end like in English, the French structure is essentially "you to-him lie" (tu lui mens).
What verb is mens from, and is it a regular -ir verb?
It comes from mentir (to lie). It is an irregular -ir verb. Similar to dormir (to sleep) or partir (to leave), it drops the "t" in its singular present tense forms: je mens, tu mens, il ment.
Why do we say mens souvent when English says "often lie"?
In French, short adverbs like souvent (often) usually go immediately after the conjugated verb. You cannot put an adverb between the subject pronoun (tu) and the verb (mens).

Learn Est-ce que tu lui mens souvent and more in French

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free
Start learning French →