Question 1

Why does التدريب take the accusative case here?

Accepted Answer

The connector إلا أن ends with أنّ, which acts exactly like إنّ. This means it requires the noun immediately following it to be in the accusative case (mansub). Therefore, the subject becomes التدريبَ.

Question 2

Since التدريب is affected by إلا أن, what happens to the adjective المكثف?

Accepted Answer

An adjective must match the case of the noun it modifies. Because التدريب was forced into the accusative case by the connector, its adjective المكثف must also be accusative.

Question 3

Why does the word ممتاز remain in the nominative case instead of changing like the words before it?

Accepted Answer

ممتاز is the predicate (the news or information) of the clause introduced by أنّ. While أنّ changes its subject to the accusative case, its predicate always remains in the default nominative case (marfu).

Question 4

In the first clause, why is the adjective صعبة feminine singular when it follows the plural word الرياضيات?

Accepted Answer

صعبة is describing the first word of the idafa structure, مسألة (problem), not الرياضيات (mathematics). Because مسألة is a feminine singular noun, the adjective describing it must also be feminine singular.

Question 5

How does إلا أن differ in nuance from a simpler word like لكن in this sentence?

Accepted Answer

Grammatically they are very similar, as both take an accusative subject. However, إلا أن is a more formal connector that translates closer to 'except that' or 'nevertheless'. It acknowledges the previous statement as true but introduces a strong contrasting fact that changes the overall situation.

مسألة الرياضيات صعبة، إلا أن التدريب المكثف ممتاز.

Breakdown of مسألة الرياضيات صعبة، إلا أن التدريب المكثف ممتاز.

Questions & Answers about مسألة الرياضيات صعبة، إلا أن التدريب المكثف ممتاز.

Learn مسألة الرياضيات صعبة، إلا أن التدريب المكثف ممتاز and more in Arabic