Question 1

Why does واضحا end with an extra alif (ـا)?

Accepted Answer

This is because واضحا (obvious) is the predicate of صار (became). صار belongs to a group of verbs known as the sisters of Kana. When they enter a sentence, they force their predicate into the accusative case, which is shown here by the "an" sound (tanwin fatha) and the extra alif.

Question 2

Is there a difference between using صار and أصبح for "became" in this sentence?

Accepted Answer

They are very similar and often interchangeable. However, صار specifically emphasizes a complete change of state (the door was clean, but now it is dirty). أصبح is also widely used for "became," but originally refers to a change happening in the morning. For a simple change of physical condition like this, صار is a perfect fit.

Question 3

If I just wanted to say "The dirt is obvious" without "became," how would the grammar change?

Accepted Answer

Without صار, you have a basic nominal sentence: الوسخ واضح على الباب (The dirt is obvious on the door). In this basic sentence, واضح takes the default nominative case, meaning it would end with an "un" sound instead of "an". Adding صار to the sentence is exactly what forces the change to واضحا.

Question 4

Does the word order have to be Verb-Subject-Predicate here?

Accepted Answer

Yes, this is the most natural word order in Modern Standard Arabic. Even though they act on noun sentences, verbs like صار usually follow the standard Verb-Subject pattern. The verb صار comes first, followed immediately by its subject الوسخ (the dirt), and then the predicate واضحا (obvious).

صار الوسخ واضحا على الباب.

Breakdown of صار الوسخ واضحا على الباب.

Questions & Answers about صار الوسخ واضحا على الباب.

Learn صار الوسخ واضحا على الباب and more in Arabic