Wildlife photography and sonder dat (without [someone] …-ing)
When the same subject does both actions, Afrikaans uses an infinitive with om … te: om 'n skerp beeld te kry (to get a sharp image). The same applies to without and instead of: sonder om … te (Hy neem 'n foto sonder om te praat., He takes a photo without talking.) and in plaas daarvan om … te.
When the subject changes, English says without + person + -ing (without the leopard noticing him). Afrikaans uses sonder dat (without [that]) followed by a full clause with its own subject and verb:
- Pattern: sonder dat
- subject
- (objects / adverbs) + verb
- subject
- Verb-final word order: dat introduces a subordinate clause, so the verb moves to the very end.
- Separable verbs (opstel, opmerk):
- opstel (to set up) and opmerk (to notice) have the stressed separable prefix op-.
- In a main clause in the present, the prefix splits off and goes to the end: Die voëls merk haar op.
- At the end of a clause (after a modal like wil, or inside a sonder dat clause), the prefix stays attached: opstel, opmerk.
- In the past, -ge- goes between prefix and stem (opgestel, opgemerk), and in a sonder dat clause het comes last, right after the participle: … sonder dat die voëls haar opgemerk het.
- Photography vocabulary: lens (lens), beeld (image), luiperd (leopard), and wild (wild, which takes -e before a noun: wilde diere, wild animals).
| The photographer uses a strong lens to get a sharp image. | Die fotograaf gebruik 'n sterk lens om 'n skerp beeld te kry. |
| Dawid wants to set up a camera by the river to see the leopard. | Dawid wil 'n kamera by die rivier opstel om die luiperd te sien. |
| He takes a photo without the leopard noticing him. | Hy neem 'n foto sonder dat die luiperd hom opmerk. |
| She set up the camera without the birds noticing her. | Sy het die kamera opgestel sonder dat die voëls haar opgemerk het. |
Motion-activated cameras and word order after sonder dat
In a sonder dat clause, objects and object pronouns come before the clause-final verb or verb group.
- Camera-trap vocabulary: beweging (movement), aktiveer (to activate), voetpad (footpath), gids (guide), and kruip (to crawl — nader kruip, to crawl closer).
- Object pronouns before the verb: … sonder dat die dier dit hoor (… without the animal hearing it).
- Present vs. past at the clause end:
- Present: the single verb ends the clause (… sonder dat die olifante ons sien).
- Past: participle + het (… sonder dat die gids dit gehoor het).
- Questions: when the main clause is a question (Hoe kan ons nader kruip …?), only the main clause inverts; the sonder dat clause keeps its verb-final order.
| The movement activates the camera without the animal hearing it. | Die beweging aktiveer die kamera sonder dat die dier dit hoor. |
| The wild lion came close without the guide hearing it. | Die wilde leeu het naby gekom sonder dat die gids dit gehoor het. |
| How can we crawl closer without the elephants seeing us? | Hoe kan ons nader kruip sonder dat die olifante ons sien? |
Substitution with a new subject (in plaas daarvan dat)
For instead of [someone else] doing something, Afrikaans uses in plaas daarvan dat (instead of [the fact that]), again with verb-final order.
- Pattern: in plaas daarvan dat
- subject
- (objects / modifiers) + verb
- subject
- Subject pronouns, not object pronouns: English uses an object pronoun before -ing (instead of *me doing it, instead of **us waiting). Afrikaans has a full clause here, so it uses a *subject pronoun (ek, jy, ons):
- … in plaas daarvan dat jy buite staan (… instead of you standing outside)
- … in plaas daarvan dat ek dit doen (… instead of me doing it)
- … in plaas daarvan dat ons hulle soek (… instead of us looking for them)
- Modifiers before the final verb: adverbs like buite (outside), time phrases like tot vanaand (until tonight), and predicate adjectives like donker (dark, before lyk, to look / seem) all stand before the clause-final verb.
- Emphatic self: self (itself / himself / herself) stresses who performs the action: Die luiperd aktiveer self die kamera (The leopard activates the camera itself).
| The camera stays in the rain instead of you standing outside. | Die kamera bly in die reën in plaas daarvan dat jy buite staan. |
| The leopard activates the camera itself instead of me doing it. | Die luiperd aktiveer self die kamera in plaas daarvan dat ek dit doen. |
| Annelie set up the camera early instead of us waiting until tonight. | Annelie het die kamera vroeg opgestel in plaas daarvan dat ons tot vanaand wag. |
| The new lens gives a sharp image instead of everything looking dark. | Die nuwe lens gee 'n skerp beeld in plaas daarvan dat alles donker lyk. |
Summary
| Conjunction | Meaning | Word order in the subordinate clause | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| sonder dat (present) | without [someone] …-ing | subject + (object) + verb | … sonder dat die luiperd hom opmerk. |
| sonder dat (past) | without [someone] …-ing (past) | subject + (object) + participle + het | … sonder dat die gids dit gehoor het. |
| in plaas daarvan dat | instead of [someone] …-ing | subject + (object / adverb) + verb | … in plaas daarvan dat ek dit doen. |
Same subject in both clauses? Use sonder om … te / in plaas daarvan om … te instead.
