Question 1

Why is председателем in the Instrumental case instead of the Accusative like Анну?

Accepted Answer

Verbs of appointing, like назначить (to appoint), take a direct object in the Accusative (Анну) and express the new role or title in the Instrumental case (председателем). You can think of the Instrumental here as translating to "as a chairman."

Question 2

Since Anna is a woman, shouldn't the word for chairman be in a feminine form?

Accepted Answer

In Russian, many official job titles and roles, including председатель, are grammatically masculine and are used for both men and women. While colloquial feminine forms sometimes exist, the standard masculine form is expected for official appointments like this one.

Question 3

What would it mean if we used the imperfective verb назначал instead of the perfective назначил?

Accepted Answer

Using the perfective назначил shows that the appointment is a completed, one-time action with a clear result: Anna is now the chairman. The imperfective назначал would imply an ongoing process (they were in the middle of appointing her) or a repeated action.

Question 4

Can we change the word order to Комитет назначил председателем Анну?

Accepted Answer

Yes, because Russian uses cases rather than word order to show who does what. However, the word at the very end of a Russian sentence usually carries the most important new information. The current order emphasizes the role she was given (председателем). Putting Анну at the end would emphasize the person, answering the specific question "Who did they appoint?"

Комитет назначил Анну председателем.

Breakdown of Комитет назначил Анну председателем.

Questions & Answers about Комитет назначил Анну председателем.

Learn Комитет назначил Анну председателем and more in Russian