Negative accompanying action (без того, чтобы не)

Let's head to the billiards table (бильярд) where the balls (шар) lie on green baize (сукно).

A player needs a cue (кий) to make a precise stroke (удар).

Negative Accompanying Action: Same Subject

To express that one action never happens without another accompanying it, use the construction без того, чтобы не.

Literally translating to "without that, so that not...", this double negative highlights an inevitable second action. When the same subject performs both actions, the verb following не is in the Infinitive.

You can use perfective or imperfective infinitives in this construction. In the next example, the ball performs both actions (falling and bouncing off, отскочить), so we continue to use the infinitive:

Different Subjects: Using the Past Tense

As with standard чтобы clauses, if the two actions have different subjects, the verb in the subordinate clause must take the Past tense (regardless of when the action actually occurs in real time).

Here, the subject of the main clause is the stroke (удар), but the subject of the subordinate clause is the ball (шар). Because the subjects differ, отскакивать takes the past tense form отскакивал.