Questions & Answers about Pies jest duży, a kot mały.
Why is a used here instead of i (and) or ale (but)?
a is a special Polish conjunction used for comparing or contrasting two things. It often translates to "while" or "and" when pointing out a difference. i is used for simply adding things together, and ale is for strong contradictions. Since we are contrasting the dog's size with the cat's size, a is the right choice.
Why is the verb missing in the second part? Shouldn't it be "a kot jest mały"?
You could include jest (is), but Polish often drops the verb in the second half of a sentence if it is the exact same verb used in the first half. Leaving it out sounds much more natural and avoids repetition.
Why do the adjectives duży and mały both end in -y?
Both pies (dog) and kot (cat) are masculine nouns. When a masculine noun is the basic subject of the sentence, its adjectives take the masculine ending -y.
Do I always need to put a comma before a?
Yes! In Polish grammar, you must always put a comma before the conjunctions a (while/and) and ale (but).