Breakdown of Krytykując społeczeństwo, uczeń odrzuca tradycję.
uczeń
student
tradycja
tradition
krytykować
to criticize
społeczeństwo
society
odrzucać
to reject (imperfective)
Questions & Answers about Krytykując społeczeństwo, uczeń odrzuca tradycję.
Does krytykując just mean "while criticizing" here?
While the -ąc ending (contemporary adverbial participle) normally shows two actions happening at the same time ("while criticizing"), here it takes on an explanatory or causal role. It translates better as "by criticizing" or "because he criticizes." It explains how or why the student rejects tradition.
Is it possible to use krytykując if a teacher is doing the criticizing, but the student is the one rejecting tradition?
No. A strict rule for using the -ąc participle in Polish is that the subject of the participle and the subject of the main verb must be the exact same person or thing. The uczeń must be the one doing both the criticizing and the rejecting.
Both społeczeństwo and tradycję are direct objects. Why does only tradycję change its ending?
Both nouns are actually in the accusative case here! Tradycja is a feminine noun, so its accusative form takes the -ę ending to become tradycję. Społeczeństwo is a neuter noun, and neuter nouns always look exactly the same in the accusative case as they do in the nominative case.
Can we form an -ąc participle from a perfective verb if the criticism was a one-time, completed event?
No, the -ąc participle can only be formed from imperfective verbs like krytykować. It inherently describes an ongoing, simultaneous, or habitual action. To express a completed action ("Having criticized society..."), you would need a completely different participle ending in -wszy or -łszy.
Learn Krytykując społeczeństwo, uczeń odrzuca tradycję and more in Polish
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free