Breakdown of “Geçmiş olsun,” dedi veteriner; keçinin ayağı incinmiş ama yakında düzelecekmiş.
Questions & Answers about “Geçmiş olsun,” dedi veteriner; keçinin ayağı incinmiş ama yakında düzelecekmiş.
What does Geçmiş olsun mean literally, and how is it actually used?
Literally, geçmiş olsun is something like may it be in the past. In natural English, that idea does not translate directly, so it is better learned as a fixed expression.
Turkish speakers use Geçmiş olsun when someone is sick, injured, has had an accident, or has gone through some unpleasant event. It is a polite, sympathetic thing to say, similar to:
- Get well soon
- I’m sorry to hear that
- Hope it passes soon
In this sentence, the veterinarian is saying it because the goat has been hurt.
Can Geçmiş olsun be said about an animal too, or is it only for people?
Yes, it can definitely be used in situations involving animals.
If someone’s pet or farm animal is sick or injured, Turkish speakers may still say Geçmiş olsun to the owner, or even in the situation generally. The phrase is really about expressing sympathy for the bad situation, not only about human illness.
Why is it dedi veteriner instead of veteriner dedi?
Both are possible.
Turkish word order is flexible, and the most neutral order is often Subject–Object–Verb, but in narration, especially after quoted speech, dedi veteriner is very natural and stylistically common. It works a bit like English said the veterinarian.
So:
- Veteriner dedi = the veterinarian said
- Dedi veteriner = said the veterinarian
The second one can sound a little more literary or narrative in English terms, but it is completely normal in Turkish.
Why is there a semicolon after veteriner?
The semicolon is a punctuation choice that links two closely related parts:
- Geçmiş olsun, dedi veteriner
- keçinin ayağı incinmiş ama yakında düzelecekmiş
It helps show that the veterinarian first says Geçmiş olsun, and then we continue with the explanation about the goat’s condition.
A comma or a full stop could also appear in other writing styles, but the semicolon here neatly connects the quoted speech with the follow-up information.
Why is it keçinin ayağı? What grammar is that?
This is a very common Turkish structure: the genitive + possessed noun pattern.
- keçi = goat
- keçinin = of the goat / the goat’s
- ayak = foot, leg
- ayağı = its foot/leg
Together:
- keçinin ayağı = the goat’s leg
This structure is formed with:
- the owner in the genitive: keçinin
- the thing owned with a possessive suffix: ayağı
So Turkish does not normally say a separate word for its here. The possession is shown by the suffix.
Why does ayak become ayağı instead of something like ayakı?
This happens because of a common sound change in Turkish.
The base word is ayak. When a vowel-initial suffix is added, the final k often softens to ğ in many words:
- ayak → ayağı
So here:
- ayak + -(s)I (3rd person possessive suffix) → ayağı
This is not random; it is part of a regular pattern in Turkish spelling and pronunciation.
Why is there no separate word for its in keçinin ayağı?
Because Turkish usually expresses that idea with a possessive suffix, not with a separate word like English its.
In English:
- the goat’s leg
- its leg
In Turkish, the possession is built into the noun:
- keçinin ayağı
The -ı / -i / -u / -ü type possessive ending on the possessed noun often does the work that English pronouns like his/her/its would do.
What does incinmiş mean grammatically?
İncinmiş is from the verb incinmek, which means to get hurt, to be injured, or sometimes to be sore. It can also be used metaphorically for feelings, but here it is physical.
The ending -miş is very important. It often adds the sense of:
- reported information
- inferred information
- something the speaker did not directly witness firsthand
So ayağı incinmiş is not just its leg got hurt, but more like:
- its leg seems to have been injured
- apparently its leg is hurt
- its leg has been injured, it seems
In context, this sounds like the narrator is reporting the veterinarian’s assessment rather than stating it as direct firsthand fact.
Why does Turkish use -miş here instead of a plain past tense like incindi?
Because -miş and the plain past tense -di do not mean exactly the same thing.
incindi = it got hurt / was hurt
This sounds more direct and definite, as if the speaker knows it firsthand.incinmiş = apparently it got hurt / it seems it was hurt / it has been hurt
This suggests reported, inferred, or newly discovered information.
In this sentence, the use of -miş fits well because the statement is tied to what the veterinarian said. It gives a slightly indirect, report-like tone.
What does düzelecekmiş mean? Why are there two endings there?
Düzelecekmiş contains two pieces:
- düzel- = get better, recover, become normal again
- -ecek = future
- -miş = reported/inferred
So düzelecekmiş means something like:
- apparently it will get better
- the vet says it will recover
- it is said that it will improve soon
This is a very useful Turkish combination: future + -miş. It lets the speaker report someone else’s prediction or present it as indirect information.
Why do both incinmiş and düzelecekmiş have -miş?
Because the whole medical assessment is being presented indirectly, as information coming from the veterinarian.
- ayağı incinmiş = its leg is apparently injured
- yakında düzelecekmiş = apparently it will recover soon
Using -miş on both verbs keeps the same reported/inferred viewpoint throughout the sentence. It sounds like the narrator is relaying the veterinarian’s words or opinion rather than speaking from direct personal knowledge.
What exactly does yakında mean, and where can it go in the sentence?
Yakında means soon or in the near future.
Here:
- yakında düzelecekmiş = it will apparently recover soon
Its position is fairly flexible. You might also see:
- yakında düzelecekmiş
- düzelecekmiş yakında
But the version in the sentence is the most natural and neutral.
Is incinmek the same as yaralanmak?
Not exactly.
Both can relate to injury, but the nuance is different:
- incinmek often suggests to get hurt, to be injured, to be sore, sometimes mildly
- yaralanmak usually sounds more clearly like to be wounded/injured
So ayağı incinmiş can sound a bit softer or less dramatic than ayağı yaralanmış. In this sentence, it fits a situation where the leg has been hurt, but the goat is expected to recover soon.
Why is the sentence about the leg rather than saying directly that the goat was hurt?
Turkish often states the affected body part very naturally.
So instead of saying:
- The goat was hurt
Turkish may say:
- The goat’s leg was hurt
That is a very normal way to describe physical problems. It can sound more precise, because it identifies exactly what is wrong.
Could this sentence be translated more literally as the goat’s foot instead of the goat’s leg?
Yes, because ayak can refer to foot or leg, depending on context.
For animals, body-part vocabulary does not always map perfectly one-to-one with English. In many contexts, keçinin ayağı could be understood as:
- the goat’s leg
- the goat’s foot
The best English choice depends on the situation and the translation style. If the intended meaning shown to the learner is leg, that is perfectly reasonable.
What is the overall structure of the sentence?
It breaks down like this:
- Geçmiş olsun = fixed expression of sympathy
- dedi veteriner = said the veterinarian
- keçinin ayağı incinmiş = the goat’s leg has apparently been injured
- ama = but
- yakında düzelecekmiş = apparently it will recover soon
So the sentence moves from:
- sympathy,
- to the speaker identification,
- to the diagnosis,
- to a reassuring prediction.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning TurkishMaster Turkish — from “Geçmiş olsun,” dedi veteriner; keçinin ayağı incinmiş ama yakında düzelecekmiş to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions