Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching Spanish grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about La ciudad es grande y bonita.
Why do we use "es" instead of "está" in this sentence?
We use es because we are describing a permanent or essential characteristic of the city (it being large and pretty). In Spanish, estar often relates to temporary states or locations, while ser focuses on inherent qualities or long-term attributes.
Why is "ciudad" feminine and how does that affect the adjectives?
In Spanish, every noun has a gender, and ciudad is feminine. Because of this, the adjectives used to describe it also need to be feminine. That's why we say grande (which stays the same for both masculine and feminine) and bonita (feminine form), rather than bonito.
Could we say "La ciudad está grande"?
While it's grammatically possible, in Spain it would sound unusual. Using está in this context would imply a temporary state or maybe a sense of surprise (as if the city has grown larger than expected). Generally, es is preferred for describing the inherent qualities of a city.
Is there a reason we don't change "grande" to "gran" in this sentence?
You can use gran before a singular noun to mean "great" (e.g., una gran ciudad = a great city). However, grande comes after the noun here and it literally means "big/large." Using gran instead would slightly change the meaning, emphasizing its importance rather than its size.
Why do we use "y" and not "e" between "grande" and "bonita"?
In Spanish, we switch y (and) to e only when the next word starts with the same sound as i (i- or hi-). Since bonita starts with a b sound, we keep y. For example, if we were saying grande e increíble (big and incredible), we would switch to e because increíble starts with the vowel i.
Your questions are stored by us to improve Elon.io
You've reached your AI usage limit
Sign up to increase your limit.