Questions & Answers about El hueso está roto.
Why is it está and not es?
Because Spanish usually uses estar for a state or condition, and broken is being treated as a condition here.
- El hueso está roto = The bone is broken
- estar + adjective often describes how something is at the moment
Using es roto would sound wrong in normal Spanish. With roto, you almost always use estar when you mean something is in a broken state.
Why is it roto and not rota?
Why does the sentence start with el?
Is hueso masculine? How do I know?
How do you pronounce hueso?
Why is there an accent mark on está?
The accent mark shows where the stress goes: es-TÁ.
It also helps distinguish está from esta:
- está = is
- esta = this (feminine), as in esta casa = this house
So the accent is important both for pronunciation and for meaning.
What exactly is roto? Is it an adjective or a verb form?
It is both historically a past participle and, in this sentence, it works like an adjective.
It comes from the verb romper = to break.
- romper → roto = broken
In El hueso está roto, roto describes the condition of the bone, so it behaves like an adjective.
This is very common in Spanish:
- La puerta está abierta = The door is open
- El vaso está roto = The glass is broken
Could I also say El hueso se ha roto?
Yes, but it means something slightly different.
El hueso está roto = The bone is broken
This focuses on the current state.El hueso se ha roto = The bone has broken / The bone has become broken
This focuses more on the event happening.
So:
- está roto = result/state
- se ha roto = action/event leading to that result
Both are correct, but they are not used in exactly the same way.
Can I say El roto hueso instead of El hueso roto?
Normally, no. In Spanish, descriptive adjectives like roto usually come after the noun.
So the normal form is:
- el hueso roto = the broken bone
Putting roto before the noun would sound very unnatural here. For most everyday Spanish, use noun + adjective in this kind of phrase.
How would I make this sentence plural?
What is the basic sentence structure here?
If I am talking about my own bone, why doesn’t Spanish use my?
Spanish often uses the definite article with body parts instead of a possessive like my, especially when the owner is already clear from the context.
For example, Spanish often prefers something like:
- Se me ha roto el hueso = I’ve broken a bone / literally, The bone has broken on me
Or:
- Me duele el brazo = My arm hurts / literally, The arm hurts me
So using el with body parts is very normal in Spanish.
Does El hueso está roto sound natural on its own?
Yes, it is grammatically correct and natural, but by itself it sounds a bit context-dependent, because the bone usually refers to a specific bone already being discussed.
For example, it fits naturally in situations like:
- a doctor looking at an X-ray
- someone talking about an injury
- a vet examining an animal
If you wanted a more general statement, Spanish might use a different structure depending on the context. But as a normal sentence meaning The bone is broken, it is perfectly fine.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from El hueso está roto to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions