Breakdown of У них хорошие отношения.
Questions & Answers about У них хорошие отношения.
Why does the sentence start with у них? What does у mean here?
In this sentence, у них is a very common Russian pattern meaning something like with them / among them / in their case.
Literally, у often means by, near, at, but in many expressions it is used more abstractly. Here, у них хорошие отношения means that they have a good relationship or their relations are good.
This is a normal Russian way to express what English often says with have:
- У меня есть время = I have time
- У него друзья = He has friends
- У них хорошие отношения = They have a good relationship / They are on good terms
So у них does not mean physical location here. It introduces the people whose relationship is being described.
Why is it них and not они?
Because они is the nominative form, used for the subject of a sentence, while них is the form required after the preposition у.
Russian pronouns change form depending on their grammatical role:
- они = they
- их / них = forms used in other cases, including after some prepositions
After у, you need the genitive case, so:
- у меня
- у тебя
- у него
- у неё
- у нас
- у вас
- у них
Also notice that after a preposition, Russian often uses the form with н-:
- у них
- к нему
- с ней
So у они would be ungrammatical.
Is there a missing verb in this sentence?
Yes — in a sense.
In the present tense, Russian usually does not use a word for is/are in sentences like this. So:
- У них хорошие отношения.
literally looks like - With them good relations.
But the understood meaning is:
- They have a good relationship or
- Their relationship is good or
- They are on good terms
This is completely normal in Russian. Compare:
- Он дома. = He is at home
- Она врач. = She is a doctor
- У них хорошие отношения. = They have a good relationship
In past or future, a form of быть appears:
- У них были хорошие отношения. = They had a good relationship
- У них будут хорошие отношения. = They will have a good relationship
Why is хорошие spelled that way?
Because хорошие has to agree with отношения in number, gender, and case.
The noun отношения is:
- plural
- nominative here
So the adjective must also be:
- plural
- nominative
That gives:
- хорошие отношения
Compare:
- хорошее отношение = a good attitude / a good relation (singular neuter)
- хорошие отношения = good relations / a good relationship (plural)
This is standard adjective-noun agreement in Russian.
Why is отношения plural? Why not singular?
In Russian, отношения is very commonly used in the plural to mean relations or relationship between people.
So even when English often says relationship in the singular, Russian often prefers the plural:
- хорошие отношения
- плохие отношения
- дружеские отношения
The singular отношение exists, but it often means something slightly different, such as:
- attitude
- approach
- relation in a more abstract sense
For example:
- Моё отношение к этому отрицательное. = My attitude toward this is negative.
So in your sentence, the plural отношения is the natural choice for talking about how two or more people get along.
What case is отношения here?
Here отношения is in the nominative plural.
Why? Because it is the main noun being described:
- У них = prepositional phrase giving the context
- хорошие отношения = the core statement, literally good relations
You can think of the structure as:
- [With them] [good relations]
Since отношения is the thing being asserted about them, it appears in the nominative.
Can the word order change?
Yes, Russian word order is flexible, though some versions sound more natural in certain contexts.
The neutral order is:
- У них хорошие отношения.
You might also hear:
- Хорошие отношения у них.
That version can sound more contrastive or emphatic, as if focusing on good relations or contrasting them with someone else.
In ordinary conversation, У них хорошие отношения is the most natural default order.
Could I also say Они в хороших отношениях?
Yes, that is also correct, and it means almost the same thing: They are on good terms.
Compare:
У них хорошие отношения.
Slightly more neutral; literally They have good relations.Они в хороших отношениях.
More like They are in a good relationship / on good terms.
Both are common. The first is a very basic and useful pattern. The second uses:
- в
- хороших отношениях = in good relations / on good terms
So both are good to know, but the original sentence is extremely standard.
Could I say между ними хорошие отношения instead?
Yes, Между ними хорошие отношения is also possible.
That version emphasizes the relationship between them:
- между ними = between them
Compare the nuance:
- У них хорошие отношения. = They have a good relationship / They are on good terms
- Между ними хорошие отношения. = There are good relations between them
The difference is small, but между ними focuses more explicitly on the connection linking the two sides.
How do you pronounce них?
Них is pronounced roughly like neekh, with a soft n and a vowel similar to ee in see.
A few helpful notes:
- у них sounds like oo neekh
- the stress in них is on the only vowel: них
- in normal speech, у них flows together smoothly
The whole sentence is pronounced approximately:
- oo neekh kha-RO-shi-ye at-na-SHE-ni-ya
Stress:
- у НИХ
- хоРОшие
- отноШЕния
Does отношения always mean romantic relationships?
No. Отношения is broader than that.
Depending on context, it can mean:
- personal relations
- professional relations
- diplomatic relations
- family relations
- romantic relationship
So У них хорошие отношения could mean:
- they get along well
- they are on good terms
- they have a good working relationship
- they have a good personal relationship
If Russian wants to make the romantic meaning clearer, the context usually does that, or a more specific phrase may be used.
What are some useful variations of this sentence?
This pattern is very productive. You can replace the adjective to describe different kinds of relationships:
- У них плохие отношения. = They have a bad relationship.
- У них дружеские отношения. = They have friendly relations.
- У них деловые отношения. = They have a business relationship.
- У них напряжённые отношения. = They have tense relations.
- У них близкие отношения. = They have a close relationship.
- У них сложные отношения. = They have a complicated relationship.
This makes у + pronoun/person + adjective + отношения a very useful pattern to remember.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning RussianMaster Russian — from У них хорошие отношения to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions