Breakdown of Эту операцию можно оспорить.
Questions & Answers about Эту операцию можно оспорить.
Why is it эту, not эта?
Because эту is the accusative singular feminine form of эта.
In Эту операцию можно оспорить, the noun операцию is the direct object of оспорить, so the demonstrative this has to agree with it in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: accusative
So:
- nominative: эта операция = this operation
- accusative: эту операцию = this operation as an object
Why does операция become операцию?
For the same reason: it is in the accusative case.
The dictionary form is операция.
Feminine nouns ending in -ия usually change like this in the singular:
- nominative: операция
- accusative: операцию
Here it is the thing being challenged, so Russian marks it as the direct object.
What exactly does можно mean here?
Можно means it is possible, it is allowed, or more naturally here, can be.
So можно + infinitive is a very common Russian pattern meaning:
- it is possible to ...
- one can ...
- ... can be ... in natural English
So:
- Эту операцию можно оспорить
= This operation can be challenged = literally, It is possible to challenge this operation
Russian uses this impersonal structure very often where English might use can.
Is this sentence passive?
Not formally, no.
In English, This operation can be challenged sounds passive.
But in Russian, Эту операцию можно оспорить is built differently:
- можно = impersonal it is possible
- оспорить = active infinitive to challenge
- эту операцию = direct object
So the literal structure is closer to:
- This operation, it is possible to challenge
Russian often uses this kind of impersonal construction instead of a passive one.
Why is the verb оспорить and not оспаривать?
Оспорить is perfective, while оспаривать is imperfective.
Here, the perfective verb is natural because the sentence talks about the possibility of completing a single action:
- оспорить = to challenge successfully / to contest as a whole
- оспаривать = to be challenging / to challenge repeatedly or as a process
With можно + infinitive, Russian often uses the perfective when it means it is possible to do this action in a specific case.
So:
- Эту операцию можно оспорить = This operation can be challenged
- Эту операцию можно оспаривать would sound less natural here and would suggest an ongoing or repeated process.
What is the dictionary form of оспорить, and what verb pair does it belong to?
The dictionary form here is already оспорить.
Its aspect pair is:
- оспаривать = imperfective
- оспорить = perfective
This is a common thing to learn with Russian verbs: many verbs come in aspect pairs, and you usually need to know both.
Why is эту операцию at the beginning? Could I say Можно оспорить эту операцию?
Yes, you absolutely could say Можно оспорить эту операцию.
Both are grammatical, but the word order changes the focus a bit.
- Эту операцию можно оспорить
puts this operation up front, making it the topic or focus - Можно оспорить эту операцию
sounds a bit more neutral: It is possible to challenge this operation
Russian word order is more flexible than English word order, and it is often used to show emphasis or information structure rather than basic grammar.
Who is able to challenge it? The sentence does not say.
Exactly. The sentence is impersonal, so it does not name the person who can do the action.
It simply says that challenging the operation is possible.
Depending on context, it could mean:
- someone can challenge it
- one can challenge it
- it can be challenged
- the customer / bank / lawyer can challenge it if that is understood from context
If you want to name the person, Russian would usually say so directly, for example:
- Клиент может оспорить эту операцию. = The client can challenge this transaction.
- Мы можем оспорить эту операцию. = We can challenge this transaction.
Could можно mean allowed to instead of possible to?
Yes, можно can mean either it is possible or it is allowed, depending on context.
For example:
- Здесь можно курить. = You may smoke here / It is allowed to smoke here
- Эту дверь можно открыть. = This door can be opened / It is possible to open this door
In Эту операцию можно оспорить, the most natural meaning is it is possible to challenge it, not really you are permitted to challenge it, although legal or procedural permission could be part of the context.
How would this sentence be pronounced, and where is the stress?
The stress is:
- э́ту
- опера́цию
- мо́жно
- оспо́рить
So you can mark it as:
Э́ту опера́цию мо́жно оспо́рить.
A rough pronunciation guide:
- эту ≈ EH-too
- операцию ≈ a-pye-RA-tsi-yu
- можно ≈ MOZH-na
- оспорить ≈ as-PO-rʲitʹ
Can I translate this literally as This operation can challenge?
No. In English that would mean the operation itself is doing the challenging, which is not what the Russian says.
Even though Russian uses an active infinitive, the meaning is:
- This operation can be challenged
- It is possible to challenge this operation
So the natural English translation is passive, even though the Russian grammar is not a standard passive construction.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning RussianMaster Russian — from Эту операцию можно оспорить to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions