Breakdown of У одного цветка бутон ещё закрыт, а у другого уже видно белые лепестки.
Questions & Answers about У одного цветка бутон ещё закрыт, а у другого уже видно белые лепестки.
Why does the sentence use у одного цветка instead of на одном цветке?
Because у + genitive here means something like as for / with / on the case of that flower. It is very natural in Russian when talking about a feature or part belonging to something:
- У цветка бутон закрыт = The flower’s bud is closed / On the flower, the bud is closed
If you said на одном цветке, that would sound more spatial and literal: on one flower. That works when something is physically located on the flower. But here Russian prefers у because the bud and petals are being described as parts/features of the flower.
Why are одного and цветка in the genitive case?
Because the preposition у requires the genitive.
So:
- цветок → цветка
- один → одного
That is why you get у одного цветка.
Why is there just у другого in the second half, not у другого цветка?
Because цветка is omitted as understood from the first half.
So the full underlying structure is:
- У одного цветка бутон ещё закрыт, а у другого цветка уже видно белые лепестки.
Russian often drops repeated words when the meaning is obvious. English does the same:
- one flower ... the other
Does другого mean different here or the other?
Here it means the other one.
In the pattern у одного ..., а у другого ..., Russian is contrasting two items:
- one ... the other ...
So другой does not mainly mean different here; it means another/the other in a pairwise contrast.
Why is бутон in the nominative case?
Because бутон is the subject of the first clause.
The structure is:
- бутон ещё закрыт = the bud is still closed
So:
- бутон = subject, nominative
- закрыт = predicate
The phrase у одного цветка just gives the frame: as for one flower / on one flower.
Why is it закрыт, not закрытый?
Because закрыт is the short form, which is commonly used in predicates:
- Бутон закрыт. = The bud is closed.
By contrast, закрытый is the full form, usually used before a noun:
- закрытый бутон = a closed bud
So:
- закрытый бутон = adjective modifying a noun
- бутон закрыт = predicate statement
What do ещё and уже add to the sentence?
They create a time/contrast relationship:
- ещё = still
- уже = already
So the sentence contrasts two stages:
- one flower’s bud is still closed
- the other flower already shows white petals
This makes the comparison much clearer and more natural.
Why is а used instead of и?
Because а marks a contrast or comparison.
Here the sentence is not just adding information; it is comparing two flowers:
- one flower is at one stage
- the other is at a later stage
So а is better than и because it means something like:
- while
- whereas
- but
What exactly is видно here?
Видно is an impersonal predicate meaning:
- it is visible
- you can see
- can be seen
So:
- у другого уже видно белые лепестки literally feels like with the other one, it is already possible to see white petals
This is a very common Russian way to talk about visibility without making a normal personal subject.
Why is it видно, not видны?
Because this sentence uses an impersonal construction.
- видно = it is visible / one can see
- видны = plural form agreeing with лепестки
So Russian has two possible ways to say something similar:
- У другого уже видно белые лепестки.
- У другого уже видны белые лепестки.
The first is impersonal and focuses on the fact that the petals can now be seen. The second makes лепестки the grammatical subject: the white petals are already visible.
Both are possible, but видно is very natural here.
What case is белые лепестки?
It is best understood here as accusative plural, the object of видно.
But for inanimate plural nouns, the accusative and nominative look the same:
- nominative plural: белые лепестки
- accusative plural: белые лепестки
So the form does not change, which is why it can be confusing.
Compare with a singular example where the case is clearer:
- Видно белый лепесток / Видно белые лепестки
- С горы видно реку = You can see the river from the hill
Could the word order be different?
Yes. Russian word order is flexible, though different orders change emphasis.
For example, you could also say:
- У одного цветка бутон ещё закрыт, а у другого уже видны белые лепестки.
- Бутон у одного цветка ещё закрыт, а у другого уже видно белые лепестки.
The original order is natural because it sets up a neat contrast:
- у одного ...
- а у другого ...
That makes the comparison easy to follow.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning RussianMaster Russian — from У одного цветка бутон ещё закрыт, а у другого уже видно белые лепестки to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions