Breakdown of Перед подменой воды воду начали отстаивать.
Questions & Answers about Перед подменой воды воду начали отстаивать.
In this context, подмена воды is a set expression, especially common in aquarium and fishkeeping language. It means changing/replacing the water, often part of the water, not necessarily all of it.
A learner might expect замена воды, but подмена воды is very natural in this specific context.
Outside this context, подмена can also mean substitution in a more negative sense, like swapping one thing for another.
Because the preposition перед normally takes the instrumental case when it means before.
So:
- подмена → nominative
- подменой → instrumental singular
That is why you get перед подменой воды.
Compare:
- перед уроком = before the lesson
- перед поездкой = before the trip
They are different cases because they do different jobs in the sentence.
- подмена воды: воды is genitive, because it depends on the noun подмена and means replacement of water
- воду начали отстаивать: воду is accusative, because it is the direct object of отстаивать
So even though both forms come from вода, they are not interchangeable here.