Breakdown of Нет бы ей использовать мебельный чехол — она поцарапала стол.
Questions & Answers about Нет бы ей использовать мебельный чехол — она поцарапала стол.
Нет бы is an idiomatic expression of reproach or criticism. It means something like:
- she could have at least...
- instead, she should have...
- why didn’t she just...
So Нет бы ей использовать мебельный чехол — она поцарапала стол means roughly:
- She should have used a furniture cover, but instead she scratched the table.
The phrase is emotionally colored: the speaker is annoyed and thinks the better choice was obvious.
Because the construction is:
нет бы + dative + infinitive
So:
- ей = to her / for her
- использовать = to use
Literally, the grammar is something like:
- Why wasn’t it for her to use...
- or She could have just used...
But in natural English, you would not translate it literally. The important thing is that нет бы regularly takes the person in the dative case.
Examples:
- Нет бы мне промолчать. = I should have just kept quiet.
- Нет бы ему позвонить. = He could have just called.