Breakdown of Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
Questions & Answers about Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
Why does the sentence begin with melihat? Is it a verb or something like seeing in English?
Here melihat is a verb, but the whole phrase melihat lembu yang sakit itu functions like a noun idea: seeing the sick cow.
So the structure is roughly:
- Melihat lembu yang sakit itu = Seeing the cow that was sick
- membuat kami berasa kasihan = made us feel pity
This is very natural in Malay. A verb phrase can act as the subject of a sentence, much like an English -ing phrase:
- Running every day is healthy.
- Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
So yes, it behaves a lot like English seeing.
What exactly does yang sakit mean here?
Yang introduces a describing clause, similar to who, which, or that in English.
So:
- lembu = cow
- sakit = sick / ill
- lembu yang sakit = the cow that is sick / the sick cow
In this sentence, yang sakit tells you which cow is being talked about.
A few similar examples:
- budak yang tinggi = the child who is tall
- rumah yang besar = the house that is big
- orang yang saya jumpa = the person whom I met
Why is itu placed after sakit instead of directly after lembu?
In Malay, itu usually comes at the end of the whole noun phrase.
So:
- lembu yang sakit itu = that sick cow / the cow that is sick
Not:
- lembu itu yang sakit unless you mean something different, like the cow is the one that is sick
This is an important pattern:
- buku merah itu = that red book
- orang yang memakai topi itu = that person wearing a hat
So itu comes after all the words that describe the noun.
Does itu mean that or the here?
It can feel like either, depending on context.
Literally, itu means that, but in many sentences it also helps mark something as specific, so in natural English it may be translated as the.
So:
- lembu yang sakit itu could be:
- that sick cow
- the sick cow
Malay does not use articles exactly like English a/an/the, so words like itu often help show definiteness.
Why is there no word for the before lembu?
Malay does not have articles like English a, an, and the.
Instead, specificity is usually understood from context or shown by words like:
- itu = that / the specific one
- ini = this
So English needs the sick cow, but Malay can say:
- lembu yang sakit itu
without needing a separate word exactly equal to the.
What does membuat kami berasa kasihan literally mean?
Literally, it means something like:
- made us feel pity
Breakdown:
- membuat = to make / cause
- kami = us
- berasa = to feel
- kasihan = pity / sympathy
So the whole part means that seeing the cow caused an emotional reaction in us.
A very literal gloss would be:
- Seeing the sick cow made us feel pity.
Why is it berasa kasihan? Could it just be kasihan?
Yes, both are possible, but they are slightly different in style and structure.
- berasa kasihan = to feel pity / to feel sorry
- kasihan by itself can also express pity, often more directly
So these are all possible depending on style:
- membuat kami berasa kasihan
- membuat kami rasa kasihan
- membuat kami kasihan — less natural in this exact structure
- kami berasa kasihan
- kami kasihan akan lembu itu — more formal/literary style
In modern everyday Malay, rasa kasihan or berasa kasihan is very natural.
What is the difference between berasa and rasa?
Both relate to feeling, but:
- berasa is a little more formal or standard in writing
- rasa is very common in everyday speech
So:
- kami berasa kasihan = slightly more careful/standard
- kami rasa kasihan = very natural in conversation
Both are correct.
Why is kami used instead of kita?
Malay distinguishes between two kinds of we/us:
- kami = we/us, excluding the listener
- kita = we/us, including the listener
So membuat kami berasa kasihan means:
- it made us feel sorry, but not necessarily you
If the speaker wanted to include the listener, they could say:
- membuat kita berasa kasihan
This is a very important difference in Malay.
Could the sentence be rewritten as Kami berasa kasihan melihat lembu yang sakit itu?
Yes, absolutely. That is also natural.
Compare:
Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
- Seeing the sick cow made us feel pity.
- More focused on the act of seeing as the cause.
Kami berasa kasihan melihat lembu yang sakit itu.
- We felt sorry on seeing the sick cow.
- More focused on we felt sorry.
Both are correct; the emphasis is just a little different.
Why use melihat instead of some other word like nampak or tengok?
These words are related, but not identical:
- melihat = to see, to look at; fairly neutral and standard
- tengok = to look/watch; very common in speech, slightly less formal
- nampak = to be visible / to see / to notice, depending on context
In this sentence, melihat works well because it is a clear, standard way to say seeing.
Possible alternatives:
Tengok lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
- understandable, but a bit more conversational
Nampak lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
- possible in speech, but less neat in standard written style
So melihat is a good choice for a model sentence.
Is kasihan only a noun, or can it also be like an adjective?
Kasihan is flexible. Depending on the sentence, it can behave like:
- pity as a noun-like idea
- pitiful or deserving pity
- an exclamation meaning poor thing!
Examples:
- Saya berasa kasihan. = I feel pity / I feel sorry.
- Budak itu kasihan. = That child is pitiful / poor child.
- Kasihan! = Poor thing!
So in your sentence, berasa kasihan means to feel pity/sympathy.
Is this sentence formal, neutral, or colloquial?
It sounds mostly neutral to slightly formal, especially because of:
- melihat instead of tengok
- berasa instead of rasa
A more conversational version might be:
- Tengok lembu yang sakit itu buat kami rasa kasihan.
A more standard/written version is the original:
- Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan.
So the original is very suitable for textbook or standard written Malay.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning MalayMaster Malay — from Melihat lembu yang sakit itu membuat kami berasa kasihan to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions