Breakdown of Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan dalam mesyuarat agung.
Questions & Answers about Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan dalam mesyuarat agung.
Why does the sentence start with Yuran penyelenggaraan?
Because Malay often puts the topic or the thing being talked about first. In this sentence, yuran penyelenggaraan means maintenance fee, and it is the thing that was discussed.
So the structure is roughly:
Yuran penyelenggaraan + dibincangkan + dalam mesyuarat agung
maintenance fee + was discussed + in/at the general meeting
This is very natural in Malay, especially with passive sentences.
What does yuran penyelenggaraan mean exactly?
Yuran means fee, charge, or sometimes dues.
Penyelenggaraan means maintenance.
So yuran penyelenggaraan = maintenance fee.
This phrase is common in contexts like apartment buildings, housing complexes, or property management, where residents pay a fee for upkeep.
What is penyelenggaraan, and how is it formed?
Penyelenggaraan is a noun meaning maintenance. It comes from the root selenggara, which relates to maintaining, servicing, or keeping something in working order.
The pattern peN-...-an often forms nouns in Malay, especially abstract nouns or names of processes/activities.
So:
- selenggara = maintain / service
- penyelenggaraan = maintenance
This is similar to how English can turn a verb into a noun, like maintain → maintenance.
Why is it dibincangkan instead of membincangkan?
Because dibincangkan is a passive form, while membincangkan is an active form.
- membincangkan = to discuss / discusses
- dibincangkan = is discussed / was discussed
In this sentence, the focus is on the maintenance fee, not on who discussed it. That is why the passive is used.
Compare:
Ahli-ahli membincangkan yuran penyelenggaraan.
The members discussed the maintenance fee.Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan dalam mesyuarat agung.
The maintenance fee was discussed in the general meeting.
What does the prefix di- mean here?
The prefix di- usually marks the passive voice in standard Malay.
So:
- bincang = discuss
- dibincangkan = was discussed / is discussed
It tells you that the subject is receiving the action, not doing it.
In this sentence, yuran penyelenggaraan is not doing the discussing. It is the thing being discussed.
What does the ending -kan do in dibincangkan?
The suffix -kan often has several functions in Malay, but in bincangkan / dibincangkan, it is part of the normal transitive verb form used when something is being discussed.
A useful way to think about it is:
- bincang = discuss / discussion
- membincangkan sesuatu = discuss something
- sesuatu dibincangkan = something is discussed
So in this case, -kan helps make the verb work naturally with a direct object.
You do not need to translate -kan separately every time; it is better to learn membincangkan / dibincangkan as common verb forms.
Does this sentence mean present tense or past tense?
Malay verbs usually do not change form for tense the way English verbs do. So dibincangkan by itself does not tell you clearly whether it means:
- is discussed
- was discussed
- has been discussed
The time is usually understood from context.
In many real situations, this sentence would be understood as was discussed in the annual general meeting, because meetings are usually completed events. But without context, the Malay sentence itself is tense-neutral.
Why is there no word for the?
Malay does not use articles like a, an, and the the same way English does. Very often, nouns appear without any article.
So:
- yuran penyelenggaraan can mean a maintenance fee, the maintenance fee, or just maintenance fees, depending on context.
- mesyuarat agung can mean the general meeting or a general meeting, again depending on context.
Malay relies much more on context than English does for this.
What does dalam mean here? Is it literally in?
Yes, dalam literally means in or inside, but in this sentence it is best understood as in, during, or sometimes at.
So:
- dalam mesyuarat agung = in the general meeting
- more natural English: during the general meeting or at the general meeting
Malay often uses dalam in places where English might prefer during.
What does mesyuarat agung mean? Is it the same as AGM?
Yes, very often mesyuarat agung refers to a general meeting, and in many contexts it can specifically mean an annual general meeting (AGM).
Breakdown:
- mesyuarat = meeting
- agung = grand, great, principal, major
So literally it is something like general/grand meeting, but in actual usage it often corresponds to general meeting, especially in organizations, associations, companies, or residential management bodies.
If someone wants to be fully explicit about annual general meeting, they may say:
- mesyuarat agung tahunan
where tahunan means annual.
Why is the person who discussed it not mentioned?
Because Malay often uses passive sentences when the doer is unknown, unimportant, obvious, or simply not the focus.
In this sentence, the important information is:
- what was discussed: yuran penyelenggaraan
- where/when it was discussed: dalam mesyuarat agung
The sentence does not need to say who did the discussing, because that is not the main point.
If you wanted to include the doer, you could say something like:
- Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan oleh ahli-ahli dalam mesyuarat agung.
The maintenance fee was discussed by the members in the general meeting.
Here oleh means by.
Is the word order fixed, or could it be said another way?
The given sentence is very natural, but Malay word order can be somewhat flexible depending on emphasis.
Standard version:
- Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan dalam mesyuarat agung.
You could also say:
- Dalam mesyuarat agung, yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan.
This puts more emphasis on the setting: In the general meeting, the maintenance fee was discussed.
Both are grammatical. The original version is simpler and more neutral.
How is dibincangkan pronounced?
It is roughly pronounced:
dee-bin-chang-kan
A few helpful points:
- di sounds like dee
- bincang has c pronounced like ch
- ng is the sound at the end of English song
- stress in Malay is usually not as strong as in English, so try to keep it fairly even
So dibincangkan is approximately:
dee-bin-CHANG-kan
though the stress is usually softer than that in natural Malay.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning MalayMaster Malay — from Yuran penyelenggaraan dibincangkan dalam mesyuarat agung to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions